[交流] 二审修改稿投出去了, 继续祈福中,每个虫子3个金币, 中了再散200！ 已有1人参与

二审修改了半个月，终于把修改稿投出了，继续祈福，但愿顺利！每个虫子仨金币了！中了再散金200！ ----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 二审意见回来了，改成Minor revision了，但是审稿人还是在纠结一个技术问题，给了一个月修改时间，继续发金币祈福，每人2个，麻烦各位虫子回复字数多一点，免得被系统判为简单回复，没法发金币，多谢各位虫友！中了再追加200金币 Reviewer Comments: Reviewer #1 Evaluations: RECOMMENDATION: Publish in APL with mandatory revision (minor) Paper Interesting: Yes Original Paper: Yes Sufficient Physics: Yes Well Organized: Yes Clear and Error Free: Yes Conclusions Supported: Yes Appropriate Title: Yes Good Abstract: Yes Satisfactory English: Yes Adequate References: Yes Clear Figures: Yes OVERALL RATING: Very Good ----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ APL初审意见如下，审稿人提的几个意见已经逐条回复了, 目前正在二审中，最担心的就是初审意见中的original paper: No, 这可是关键标准啊，不知道审稿人能不能善心大发，给我改成yes， 已经11天了，各种忐忑，散300金币祈福，中了再散200！！！ ps，哪位大神遇到过original paper： no的情况么，求交流 初审意见 Reviewer Comments: Reviewer #1 Evaluations: RECOMMENDATION: Reconsider for APL after mandatory revision (major) Paper Interesting: Yes Original Paper: No Sufficient Physics: Yes Well Organized: Yes Clear and Error Free: Yes Conclusions Supported: No Appropriate Title: No Good Abstract: Yes Satisfactory English: Yes Adequate References: No Clear Figures: Yes OVERALL RATING: Good 二审进度 All Reviewers Secured        20-Feb-2015 11:52:26 Review Started        20-Feb-2015 11:52:26 First Reviewer Secured        20-Feb-2015 11:52:26 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review        20-Feb-2015 11:52:26 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent        11-Feb-2015 21:27:22 Potential Reviewers Selected        11-Feb-2015 21:27:08 Reviewer Assignment Started        11-Feb-2015 12:14:36 Securing Associate Editor        11-Feb-2015 12:14:35 Securing Editor        11-Feb-2015 12:14:35 Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed        11-Feb-2015 12:14:35 Submission Check by Editorial Office Started        11-Feb-2015 10:24:10 Securing Editor        11-Feb-2015 10:24:10 Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office        11-Feb-2015 10:24:09 Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files        11-Feb-2015 09:12:36 Submission Check by Editorial Office Failed        11-Feb-2015 09:12:36 Submission Check by Editorial Office Started        11-Feb-2015 01:39:58 Securing Editor        11-Feb-2015 01:39:58 Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office        11-Feb-2015 01:39:56 Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted        10-Feb-2015 22:28:59 [ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-3-25 at 22:58 ] 三审都21天了，还没结果，忐忑啊~~~~(>_<~~~~ [ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-4-24 at 20:03 ] 附上三审进度--三审整整拖了28天啊！ ----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Manuscript Sent to Production        01-May-2015 10:24:33 Manuscript Ready for Production        30-Apr-2015 22:51:54 Decision Sent to Author        30-Apr-2015 22:51:54 Decision Letter Being Prepared        30-Apr-2015 21:36:15 Associate Editor Decision Completed        30-Apr-2015 21:36:15 Associate Editor Decision Started        30-Apr-2015 20:46:47 All Reviews Received        30-Apr-2015 20:46:47 Review Received        30-Apr-2015 20:46:47 All Reviewers Secured        02-Apr-2015 14:43:24 Review Started        02-Apr-2015 14:43:24 First Reviewer Secured        02-Apr-2015 14:43:24 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review        02-Apr-2015 14:43:24 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent        26-Mar-2015 00:44:09 Potential Reviewers Selected        26-Mar-2015 00:43:58 Reviewer Assignment Started        25-Mar-2015 10:27:19 Securing Associate Editor        25-Mar-2015 10:27:19 Securing Editor        25-Mar-2015 10:27:19 Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed        25-Mar-2015 10:27:19 Submission Check by Editorial Office Started        25-Mar-2015 09:51:50 Securing Editor        25-Mar-2015 09:51:50 Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office        25-Mar-2015 09:51:49 Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted        25-Mar-2015 09:06:33 [ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:40 ] 附上三审结果，publish in APL as is.... ----------华丽的分割线------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Editor's Comments: Reviewer Comments: Reviewer #1 Evaluations: RECOMMENDATION: Publish in APL as is Paper Interesting: Yes Original Paper: Yes Sufficient Physics: Yes Well Organized: Yes Clear and Error Free: Yes Conclusions Supported: Yes Appropriate Title: Yes Good Abstract: Yes Satisfactory English: Yes Adequate References: Yes Clear Figures: Yes OVERALL RATING: Very Good Applied Physics Letters retains the top spot as the most highly cited journal in Applied Physics with an Impact Factor of 3.515 [ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:42 ] APL终于中了，从major到minor到accept as is,加上中途修改，总共历时144天，再加上老板那里压了俩月，总共搞了大半年，还好终于中了，也算给这半年工作有个交代，也祝大家paper顺利！手头有篇OE要审，明天提几个问题就给他过了，哈哈 [ Last edited by yyman660 on 2015-5-3 at 00:46 ]

回复此楼

» 本帖已获得的红花（最新10朵）

Y-Q-C

» 猜你喜欢

• 论文终于录用啦！满足毕业条件了 已经有18人回复
• 不自信的我 已经有5人回复
• 磺酰氟产物，毕不了业了！ 已经有4人回复
• 投稿Elsevier的杂志（返修），总是在选择OA和subscription界面被踢皮球 已经有8人回复

高级回复

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

• 为自己的文章祈福 已经有114人回复
• 散100金币，祝女友生日快乐和我的论文顺利接收！！！ 已经有196人回复
• 【交流】小雪要走了，散200金币留作纪念 已经有614人回复
• 【其他】明天一家三口J1J2，先散100金，求祝福 已经有247人回复