24小时热门版块排行榜

>论坛更新日志 (1713)
>硕博家园 (1014)
>虫友互识 (1009)
>导师招生 (151)
>考博 (110)
>海外博后 (100)
>博后之家 (93)
>学术会议 (60)
>休闲灌水 (42)
>催化 (33)
>招聘信息布告栏 (30)
>论文投稿 (15)
>电化学 (10)
>考研 (9)
>文献求助 (7)
>有机交流 (1)

返回列表

peifeinini

铜虫 (正式写手)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 502.1
散金: 36
红花: 7
帖子: 371
在线: 61.4小时
虫号: 484967
注册: 2007-12-27
性别: MM
专业: 色谱分析

[求助] Talanta，你这是把我当猴耍吗？已有3人参与

9月下旬投了ACS的一个杂志，因为主题跟杂志不符，被拒了，没涉及语言问题。我把格式修改后在同一天投到了Talanta上去，几天后他们来信说要technical revision，系统状态也变成sent back to author（没提及语言问题）。可是邮件里没显示需要修改的具体内容，如下：
Thank you for your recent submission to Talanta.
However, before we can send your manuscript out for review, please note that we would like you to make the following changes/corrections:

1)
2)
To make these amendments, please login to the Elsevier Editorial System as an author. The URL is http://ees.elsevier.com/tal/.

于是我直接回复说看不到他们建议的修改内容。然后是elsevior的Researcher Support回邮件说我应该在信里面写清楚reference number和杂志名称和我的联系方式等，这样他们才能做进一步处理。然后我就老老实实按要求又发了一次邮件。过了3、4天一个叫Melissa De Chavez的人回复我说已经向有关人员反应了，然后4天无下文。今天实在沉不住气就发邮件去催，Melissa立刻回复说他/她已经向他们反应过情况了，叫我不要再问他/她这件事了，等消息就好。我低声下气的道歉并客气的问ta能否给我相关负责人的联系下方式，ta说不能。。。。结果，三、四个小时后，拒信来了，说是语言不过关，还附带了两点technical revision。

Title:****
Talanta

Dear ***，

Your manuscript has been screened for possible publication in Talanta. We regret to inform you that we cannot admit the manuscript into the formal review process in its current state. Before we can send your manuscript to the Journal Editor, please make changes/corrections as mentioned in the comments below.

You are welcome to resubmit your paper as a new submission after a very careful revision, making sure that every aspect of the manuscript is in accordance with the author guidelines. This should include, but not be limited to, the comments mentioned below.

We strongly recommend you to consult our journal instructions at http://www.elsevier.com

Sincerely,

Talanta

Comments:

LANGUAGE:

In its current state, the level of English throughout your manuscript does not meet the journal's desired standard. Please check the manuscript and refine the language carefully.

TECHNICAL:

1) Pages should be numbered sequentially.

2) The manuscript source file has line numbers, but our system automatically adds line numbers to the PDF. Please save a version of the file locally that has no line numbers, and Edit submission to add this file and remove the incorrect one.

真想爆粗口了，虽然我对自己英语有信心，但talanta对语言要求高众所周知，所以当他们提出语言不合格时我是没话说的，但我不服气的是为什么第一次来信时候没拒，还只是sent back to author？拖了我那么久（这一来二去的浪费了近10天），这会儿才以语言不合格为由把我拒了，他们还把不把投稿者的时间当时间了？

虽然他们还给机会叫我修改好后再投，但想想真心凉。而且第一次遇到这样的问题，想问问过来人，如果修改好再重新提交会不会因为这次留下的不好印象而降低了被录用的几率？

回复此楼