24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

laohubinbin

银虫 (著名写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 28941
散金: 10
红花: 8
帖子: 2828
在线: 246.9小时
虫号: 891944
注册: 2009-11-03
专业: 计算机应用技术

[交流] Reconsider after Revision是什么意思？大家帮忙分析一下已有6人参与

投稿到Computerized Medical Imaging and Graphics

返回的意见没写是“大修”还是“小修”，投稿系统中显示的是“Reconsider after Revision”（第一次看到过这种Decision）
感觉编辑的对稿子态度不是很看好呢。。。

一审意见为：
I have some referee comments. We regret that your paper, in its present form, is not acceptable for publication in Computerized Medical Imaging and Graphics

However, if you care to revise it, we will reconsider it for publication.

When submitting your revised manuscript, please ensure that you upload the source files (e.g. Word). Uploading only a PDF file at this stage will create delays should your manuscript be finally accepted for publication. If your revised submission does not include the source files, we will contact you to request them.

Kindly advise of your plans to resubmit your paper.

Reviewer #1: This paper presents a new framework to estimate geometric parameters and perform the pre-bending operation of steel plate before a long bone fracture surgery. A system called "Fracture Assist" is implemented to realize the proposed framework. Five components are well designed to complete the accurate registration of the broken bone models. The novelty and presentation of the paper are good while some places need to be modified shown as follows.
1……
2……
3……

Reviewer #2: This paper presents a visual system to assist how surgeons plan to register bone fracture before operation.
……
……
（都是正面的意见）
There are some errors of sentence representation in this paper. It is hoped that the author can correct it.
In conclusion, the research of this paper has an important applicant value.

Reviewer #3: The paper deals with an interesting topic but at present the paper organisation presents many lacks in the experimental validation that doesn't underlines the advantages and disadvantages that the proposed method provide. I suggest to the authors to integrate this part making comparison with other available methodologies and proposing a more structured validation also in term of sample significance

[ Last edited by laohubinbin on 2013-12-11 at 20:22 ]

回复此楼