[求助] 文章直接被拒--materials science and engineering A 已有2人参与

等了4个月零7天，编辑说根据审稿人意见，直接reject了。本人第一次投该杂志，请问虫友们，一般收到这样的邮件用不用给编辑回信呢？邮件里只附带了一个审稿人的审稿意见，说了一些试验条件不够明确及图表格式上的问题，当然也说近五年的参考文献不多，结果及讨论不是很清楚，建议目前的稿件不发表。能否再修改一下，再请编辑给次机会呢？ Reviewers' comments: Reviewer #2: The paper presents an investigation on high temperature mechanical fatgue failure behavior of solder joint. The work is very interesting and good. The language is impressive and organisation of the paper is good. The work presented seems to be preliminary work and lacks many data enabling the reproduaction of the expeirments carried out. For example : it does not mention the period of fatigue test, nos. of samples tested and failure aftre how many cycle. The format of the manuscript is not in the standard MSEA format for tables and figures. Mechanical properties of chemical composition of the materials used need to be included. The references are not up-to-date. If we see the references for last five years, it has citation of 1 from 2011, 3 from 2009 and 1 from 2008. It needs to be updated. More clarity is needed in results and discussion part. Hence, the paper suffers is not upto the standard of MSEA and hence, the recommendation is against the publication of this manuscript in the present form.

回复此楼

» 收录本帖的淘帖专辑推荐

sci教程

» 猜你喜欢

• 论文终于录用啦！满足毕业条件了 已经有25人回复
• 2026年机械制造与材料应用国际会议 （ICMMMA 2026） 已经有3人回复
• 北京211副教授，35岁，想重新出发，去国外做博后，怎么样？ 已经有4人回复
• 自荐读博 已经有3人回复
• 求助:我三月中下旬出站，青基依托单位怎么办？ 已经有5人回复
• 不自信的我 已经有5人回复
• 磺酰氟产物，毕不了业了！ 已经有4人回复
• 投稿Elsevier的杂志（返修），总是在选择OA和subscription界面被踢皮球 已经有8人回复

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

• materials science and engineering A 投稿 已经有5人回复
• Bio-Medical Materials and Engineering未发现投稿系统 请问在哪里 已经有4人回复
• Materials Science and Engineering A与compound and alloys 已经有5人回复
• MATERIALS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING A，投稿要求有哪些？ 已经有3人回复
• Materials science and engineering A投稿 已经有4人回复
• materials science and engineering A, Decision in process 6天了 已经有21人回复
• 2012影响因子表中，Material Science and Engineering B怎么没有啊？ 已经有11人回复
• 投稿给Materials Science and Engineering A, 编辑退回来让改，麻烦各位给看一下 已经有5人回复
• Smart Materials and Structures 投了20天了，没动静啊 已经有31人回复
• Materials Science & Engineering A 上文章接收了，校稿前怎么修改通信作者？ 已经有8人回复
• Materials science and engineering A 技术审查问题 已经有8人回复
• 关于Materials Science and Engineering：C的投稿 已经有5人回复
• 投Materials Science and Engineering: A时候Responses to Technical Check位置 已经有4人回复
• Materials Science & Engineering A投稿的技术审查 已经有7人回复
• Materials Science and Engineering A状态求助 已经有13人回复
• 投Materials Science and Engineering A修改稿上传的问题 已经有4人回复
• Materials Science and Engineering B.的Prime Novelty Statement 怎么写啊？ 已经有7人回复
• Materials Science and Engineering: B的二审审稿完成，需要几天收到编辑的信件 已经有8人回复
• materials science and engineering a的under review一共三，四天就结束，估计杯具了 已经有24人回复
• Materials Science & Engineering A 投稿求助 已经有9人回复