24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

yanch000

捐助贵宾 (著名写手)

应助: 4 (幼儿园)
金币: 3244.9
散金: 4
帖子: 1666
在线: 150.8小时
虫号: 334896
注册: 2007-03-31
专业: 工程管理

[交流] 第一性原理计算还有用吗？有关碳纳米管的研究已经透彻到了的没问题了吗？已有6人参与

近日往Chinese Physics B投了一篇有关碳纳米管场致发射性能的文章，结果“砖家”的评审意见让人很质疑,且看评审意见：
Even though one dimensional carbon nanotubes have been the hot subjects in the material sciences, physics and chemistry, the field emission properties of CNTs have been investigated thoroughly and the correlated papers have been presented too much. After reading the present paper, readers cannot catch much more new insight into the properties of CNTs. Meanwhile, the calculation approach is still follow the former method reported in the literatures. Thus I do not suggest to publish this paper in CPB. If the writhers can combine some experimental results with the theoretical conclusions, the paper may be more interesting and attractive than the moment. After that, there will be a chance to be considered to publish the paper in CPB.
质疑1、有关碳纳米管的研究已经透彻到了的没问题了吗？
2、采用旧的研究方法（用的是第一性原理计算）有错吗，难道你要摒弃从小学到现在所学过的知识，一切革新重来吗？
3、目前的实验测量精度能到达单根碳纳米管的场致发射性能吗？
4、砖家你能不能说点有见识的意见啊？

回复此楼