| 查看: 5604 | 回复: 61 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖,点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
[交流]
征集审稿意见啦~~(不怕没奖励,就怕不参与)
|
|||
[ Last edited by zhtear99 on 2012-11-29 at 23:17 ] |
» 本帖已获得的红花(最新10朵)
» 本帖@通知
» 猜你喜欢
面上项目filecode邪修
已经有3人回复
应该是93bebmhtak前后十一个字符比较关键
已经有13人回复
关于代码变化问题,想知道的进来
已经有20人回复
这样的filecode谁见过
已经有21人回复
filecode与中标关系的预测
已经有5人回复
fileCode有新解读?
已经有18人回复
关于filecode,很负责任的告诉大家
已经有7人回复
【2027博士申请】纳米药物递送方向
已经有5人回复
关于豆爷回答的JTJC与%2F数量
已经有7人回复
2026国自然放榜时间
已经有3人回复
» 抢金币啦!回帖就可以得到:
发榜前的“心理过山车”:你经历了吗?
+5/270
【火热征稿中!】2026年土木建筑与水利工程国际会议(ICCHE 2026)
+1/181
三(三甲基硅基)甘油醚(CAS:6787-10-6 )
+1/88
3-羟基丙腈(CAS:109-78-4)
+1/87
乙二醇二甲基环硅醚(CAS:57915-66-9)
+1/87
1-甲基-1,2-双(三甲基硅氧基)乙烷(CAS:17887-27-3)
+1/86
1,2-双(三甲基硅氧基)乙烷(CAS:7381-30-8 )
+1/85
别研究filecode了,祝都有一个好结果:)
+2/82
中国科学技术大学-苏州国家实验室联培招生-本科直博/硕博连读/申请考核三种方式
+1/79
坐标重庆 诚征男友
+1/59
中国石油大学(华东)计算机科学与技术学院/智能化新能源系统设计和开发方向 特聘副教
+2/38
中国石油大学(华东)材料科学与工程学院/新颖能源材料智能设计和开发方向 特聘副教授
+2/33
上海交通大学诚聘有机化学方向博士生/科研助理
+1/29
浙江大学医学院附属第一医院招聘科研助理
+1/17
双一流高校招收博士(现代技术管理/环境技术经济管理)及硕士研究生(长期有效)
+1/12
高耐腐蚀性的镁合金微弧氧化工艺
+1/12
澳大利亚 Murdoch University 全奖博士招生(3个名额)地质化工冶金领域
+1/9
国防科技大学前沿交叉学科学院|光学工程|2026年博士申请-考核制招生
+1/9
福建师范大学海峡柔性电子学院-2027年9月入学博士-考核制-电催、能源
+1/7
北京理工大学-集成电路与电子学院杰青团队-招博士后
+1/2
zhtear99: 回帖置顶 2012-12-05 19:48:11
|
研究方向:计算机辅助药物设计 投稿杂志名称:International Journal of Molecular Sciences 审稿意见: Reviewer 1# 1) This paper is well organized and of interest in the field, but some points must be clarified and discussed before it can be suitable of publication. 2) On page 3, line 113: "required empirical potential energy function" must be substituted with "force field parameters" since the term is wrong. A question on page 4 paragraph lines 118-121: How can the authors be sure that the most conformational analysis been made on each of these tow compounds? This point of course is crucial for a correct alignment and thus further analysis. 3) On page 7, another perplexity: How can the authors be sure that the crystallized water are indeed structural for the template protein too? Are there any experimental evidence? I suggest to repeat the docking calculations also in absence of water inside the cleft and tentatively compare the results obtained. This point of is crucial since all the discussion about the molecular interactions is linked to structural water playing a fundamental role in stabilization. 4) On page 11, figure 5: line 322-323: "tubes" instead of "ball and stick". Reviewer 1# Considering the situation that no X-ray structure of human proteasome exists, making good models of the enzyme as inhibitor-bound form help researchers conduct SAR study efficiently. The computational studies in this manuscript almost meet the demand. However, both compounds dealt with in this manuscript are covalent inhibitors. The reviewer would like the authors to state any good reason why only non-covalent interactions were considered in the calculations. Especially, TBA is believed to make reversible borate adduct form to display proteasome-inhibitory activity, and the bound structure should be more suitable to evaluate results from SAR studies on the compounds of this class. Recalculations is requested if needed. On the top of that, the following should be considered. Line 68: What abbreviation MM means (multiple myeloma) should be indicated. Line 101: "selected considered having a similar range" is grammatically incorrect. Line 227: change energy to energetically throuout: Usually, "big" is not used scientific articles like this. Change to large, bulky or other appropriate words. 个人感想:两个审稿人给的意见都很好。两位审稿人比我还细心,我没检查出来的明显错误被他们看出来了(囧ing),而且第二个审稿人对我们做的proteasome很了解。讲一下当时投稿发生的小插曲吧。这家杂志是让投稿人自己推荐审稿人的。师姐说一般都在谷歌学术里搜一下,找几个QSAR方面的大牛就可以了。原因有二:一是大牛很厉害,可以提供很好很专业的审稿意见;二是大牛不会为难咱们这些小虾米。然后,我就这么着,找了俩大牛当审稿人。当时带我做实验的老师知道后,很光火,狠狠地训了我一顿。因为他跟这家杂志的几个审稿人很熟,如果我推荐他认识的那几个人当审稿人会比较保险。投完文章后,我惴惴不安,担心被拒,也觉得自己太自以为是了,没有事先问老师。最后,文章收到了revise。事实证明,师姐的话也是有道理的。所以说推荐审稿人的两种方式其实应该都可行的。 PS:IJMS是收费杂志,IF是2点几吧。我估摸着可能是收费的原因,所以接受率比较高吧。 [ Last edited by zhtear99 on 2012-12-1 at 14:50 ] |
52楼2012-12-01 14:41:40
lxg133298
荣誉版主 (文学泰斗)
-

专家经验: +201 - 应助: 511 (博士)
- 贵宾: 6.494
- 金币: 86353.6
- 帖子: 53470
- 在线: 6508.9小时
- 虫号: 1451437
2楼2012-11-29 16:42:12
3楼2012-11-29 16:47:48
lxg133298
荣誉版主 (文学泰斗)
-

专家经验: +201 - 应助: 511 (博士)
- 贵宾: 6.494
- 金币: 86353.6
- 帖子: 53470
- 在线: 6508.9小时
- 虫号: 1451437
4楼2012-11-29 16:55:23












回复此楼
古可ぷ

