24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

长征068

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 36.6
散金: 65
红花: 1
帖子: 21
在线: 101.2小时
虫号: 1079060
注册: 2010-08-21
性别: GG
专业: 骨、关节、软组织退行性病

[求助] 投稿Journal of Bioactive and Compatible Polymers，接收后编辑部再次要求修改

年初投稿，期间发回大修一次，修回后3个月直接接收，3天后编辑部再次发邮件要求修改，但是很多问题是大修时提过的，比如前言原来比较少，后来增加了部分内容，但是这次意见提示内容太多了，还有关于课题的创新性以及实验设计部分这个已经没法再改了，所以不知道怎么改了？难道是编辑部要反悔？好不容易中的一篇文章，请高人指点迷津，不胜感激啊！！
（该杂志是直接通过邮件投稿了，没有提交系统。中间有个小插曲，因为修回后一直没有发邮件提示已收到，但是投稿时3天后会回信收到，所以在中间曾2次发邮件提醒确认是否收到，理由是文件较大，担心邮件没有传送成功，这个按理不会让编辑部反感吧）
附上两次邮件
2012-10-16收到
BIOACTIVE AND COMPATIBLE POLYMERS
Dear Dr. xx;
Your manuscript entitled “xx” reports a simple modification on xx with little novelty. You need to emphasize how your work is enhancing our knowledge of this vigorous field. Currently, this and other necessary information is missing.

The text is full of redundant and pointless information. For example, very basic unnecessary information can be seen in the introduction (1088 words). The design of the study has some technical problems and data lack necessary information. It requires the work of someone well versed in the field and English. Breif and direct presentation of new experimental facts are required.

We are not able to process this manuscript for publication until these concerns are thoroughly addressed. The authors must recheck the manuscript as it does not seem that all of the remarks by the original reviewers have been appropriately addressed.

Editor

2012-10-13收到
Dear Dr. xx;
Your revised paper:

xx

has been received and is being scheduled for the February, 2013 Issue.

An edited copy of your paper will be sent to you in about two months for your approval. We will then send it to the publisher and it will be posted on FIRST ONLINE after your paper has been proofed. It will then be followed by the printed publication as scheduled.

Thank you for your contribution,

Raphael Ottenbrite

Editor

回复此楼