24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

mogu1981

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 5 (幼儿园)
金币: 466.3
散金: 313
红花: 1
帖子: 166
在线: 83.8小时
虫号: 733346
注册: 2009-03-28
专业: 信息处理方法与技术

[交流] 1.2的SCI给我二次修改，准备三审，是不是离接收更近了呢？已有11人参与

今天收到二审结果，意见是大修，下面是审稿人的总体评价（一审两个审稿人，二审好像是三个，估计有两个审稿人的意见不多，可能是一个同意一个不大同意，也可能是那两个都同意，但是第三个审稿人给了很多修改意见不能不改，唉乱猜）：
Reviewer #3: [Overview]

I think XXXXXXXX is interesting. The obtained results suggest that the XXXXXXXX seemed successfully achieved.
However, due to following reasons, I think that this paper should majorly be revised.
-As shown in Comment #1, it is hard to distinguish the original work and previous work from this paper.
-As shown in Comment #2, the effect of proposed method is unclear.
-As shown in Comment #18, comparison of the proposed method and conventional method is necessary.

in general, I think this manuscript contains interesting information. However, this manuscript is required to be majorly revised because of its lengthy.
大家看看是不是有希望接收啊，总共有20条修改意见，没有伤筋动骨，也没有让重做实验什么的。不过1.2的SCI竟然给了两次修改，有些惊诧，我以为这是很牛的期刊才有的待遇啊，估计是编辑还不想放弃我的稿子吧