24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

宝宝1986

铁虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 159.3
散金: 1
红花: 1
帖子: 84
在线: 24.6小时
虫号: 1004369
注册: 2010-04-23
专业: 有机合成

[求助] 急需帮助，编辑回复的意思

我刚投了一篇ACTA-E的文章，编辑回复如下Your article has been rejected on the following grounds:

The structure analysis of this compound seems to be reliable. Unfortunately, the submission is sub-standard and needs major revisions.

1. The reflection statistics of the data in the FCF (theta max 61.06 deg) is not consistent with value in the CIF file (62.7 deg). The wR2 value reported in CIF also differ from the one calculated from FCF. Please ensure that the FCF file was created in the same run where CIF was created.

2. The numbering of the atoms in the molecule is completely random. Please renumber them in a sensible and logical way.

3. Resolution of Figure 1 is too low.

4. References are not consistent with computing details. For example Diamond vs. OLEX2 and Bruker software vs. CrysAlisPro. Please check also format of citations in the computing details.

5. "...the organic molecules are in the whole plane" Do you mean that they are planar? Please give a maximum of rms deviation for the planar molecule.

6. "Molecules of the title compound are 0 dimensional." I do not understand the content of this sentence.

我想知道编辑什么意思，是直接退稿了，还是还有修改的余地，谢谢，急需帮助，希望知道的虫子，帮忙解答一下

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

文章被接收了，但编辑啥意思呢？？已经有16人回复
这个编辑意见是什么意思呢？请大家帮忙已经有6人回复
怎样回复编辑急需帮助已经有4人回复
询问编辑是什么意思？已经有14人回复
投Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics 编辑回复暂时接受但是要大修是什么意思？已经有5人回复
编辑个回复的信是什么意思啊？已经有7人回复
请问一直处于编辑加工是什么意思？已经有12人回复
急求好心人解释基金申请帮助里面的“如何编辑填写包含图表的报告正文”两段话意思！已经有6人回复
求助，编辑回复信意思已经有8人回复
首次发SCI，回复中需要re-submission。恐对编辑意思理解有偏差，望各位指点！已经有13人回复
JPCC 回复了，如下，让我选编辑，请大侠看看是什么意思？已经有18人回复
JAP询问修改稿大家帮忙编辑回复什么意思已经有13人回复

1楼2011-06-09 22:59:15

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

zcy800204

金虫 (正式写手)

CMEI: 2
应助: 13 (小学生)
金币: 1614.5
散金: 2097
红花: 10
帖子: 974
在线: 844.1小时
虫号: 267733
注册: 2006-07-23
性别: GG
专业: 有机合成

【答案】应助回帖

★ ★ ★
drg1984(金币+5): 谢谢热心帮助！ 2011-06-10 10:49:34
宝宝1986(金币+10): 2011-06-10 20:10:29
drg1984(金币-2): 对不起，多给了！ 2011-06-11 23:21:43

1. The reflection statistics of the data in the FCF (theta max 61.06 deg) is not consistent with value in the CIF file (62.7 deg). The wR2 value reported in CIF also differ from the one calculated from FCF. Please ensure that the FCF file was created in the same run where CIF was created.

你的FCF文件中最大2Theta值和CIF文件中不一致，wR2 也一样

2. The numbering of the atoms in the molecule is completely random. Please renumber them in a sensible and logical way.
原子编号有点随即，就是有点混乱，就是让把编号放在该原子旁边

3. Resolution of Figure 1 is too low.
Fig1 分辨率太低

4. References are not consistent with computing details. For example Diamond vs. OLEX2 and Bruker software vs. CrysAlisPro. Please check also format of citations in the computing details.
补参考文献，要求一致

5. "...the organic molecules are in the whole plane" Do you mean that they are planar? Please give a maximum of rms deviation for the planar molecule.
你说整个分子共平面，你确定是共平面的吗？如果是，请给最大标准偏差。

6. "Molecules of the title compound are 0 dimensional." I do not understand the content of this sentence.
你说分子是O维的，编辑不懂，到底是1维，2维还是3维，那就看你的结构了。
都是比较好解决的东东。
编辑据了，关键是你写的不行