[交流]
投Applied Physics B: Lasers and Optics，这样的拒稿意见是否冤枉？
如题。投稿近5个月，拒稿信只有一个审稿人评论，如下：
This is a paper of pure theoretical calculation without experimental support.
The idea is interesting but the paper would be greatly strengthened if the idea
were confirmed by experiment. I will not recommend acceptance of publication
of the article unless the authors can add experimental results.
主编可能怕我申诉，所以强调是终审意见：We apologize, but Applied Physics B – Lasers and Optics will not evaluate the manuscript again.
回复此楼
+3/270
