24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

xscxscxsc

木虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 4.7
散金: 1024
红花: 3
帖子: 299
在线: 550.6小时
虫号: 497220
注册: 2008-01-29
性别: GG
专业: 无机非金属基复合材料

[交流] 第一次投稿被拒，请有经验的虫们指点一下啊！已有11人参与

我是一个半月前投稿到journal of physical chemistry C，昨天收到被拒消息。这是我第一次投稿，一点经验没有，现在很纠结，请大家给点意见是经过认真修改后重新投稿还是修改后改投其它杂志比较好，我现在都博三了，非常着急，审稿意见如下：谢谢大家啦！
Reviewer: 1

Recommendation: This paper is not recommended because it does not provide new physical insights.

Comments:
Review of the manuscript (jp-2011-00693f)
By Wang et al. “Study of interfacial enhancement of carbon nanotube and carbon fiber reinforced composites”.
This manuscript presents the effect of CNTs grafted on a CF on interfacial shear strength. The models were used to estimate the interfacial shear strength of CNTs/CF reinforced composites. The idea is new. However, in this manuscript, there is no highlight result, and the novelty and scientific significance of this manuscript are lacking, and the discussion on why the interfacial shear strength of CNTs/CF reinforced composites is enhanced is superficial. In my opinion, it is not suitable for publication in J. Phys. Chem

Reviewer: 2

Recommendation: This paper is probably publishable, but should be reviewed again in revised form before it is accepted.

Comments:
Review of manuscript jp-2011-00693f

This work is an attempt to probe the reinforcing potential of Carbon Fiber (CF) grafted with carbon nano-tubes (CNTs) using molecular mechanics and molecular dynamics simulations. As far as I understand the study is based on previously published data, and on simulations of microdroplet tests.

The issue is definitely of importance and novel, and the theoretical results, as an upper boundary to the reinforcing ability of CNTs grafted fibers, are interesting. On the negative side, however, it seems to me that the authors have only input previously published data into commercial simulation software. Moreover, there is a serious lack of references to a substantial amount of recent experimental results (CNT-grafted on single fibers) published in this field, which are actually fully relevant to the theoretical calculations presented by the authors. The reference list regarding work of the last 10 years about interfacial adhesion between CNTs and polymers is very incomplete as well.

In view of this I cannot recommend publication of the manuscript in its present form.

回复此楼