²é¿´: 696  |  »Ø¸´: 3
µ±Ç°Ö»ÏÔʾÂú×ãÖ¸¶¨Ìõ¼þµÄ»ØÌû£¬µã»÷ÕâÀï²é¿´±¾»°ÌâµÄËùÓлØÌû

RoseAndy

¾èÖú¹ó±ö (ÕýʽдÊÖ)


[½»Á÷] Çë½Ì´ó¼Ò£¬ÎÒÓ¦¸ÃÈçºÎ»Ø¸´±à¼­£¿ ¿ÏÇë´ó¼ÒÖ¸µã¡£

Reviewers' comments:

Reviewer #1: This paper is well revised. The topic about **** is very interesting and meaningful, but it still needs some modifications:
(1)        Avoid question title in technical paper.
(2)        In section 2.1(line 58), the mineral filler used should be limestone powder instead of calcium carbonate.
(3)        In section 2.3(line 89), why the dimension of specimens is determined at 250 ¡Á 30 ¡Á 25 in B test?  
(4)        As far as I concerned, the results of B usually have a big error, please provide more information about error analysis
(5)        Numerous tests on correlation between A test results and C index are suggested. If the C index can take place of TSRST test results?  



Reviewer #2: The paper addresses a very important topic and, although the English used is sometimes confusing, it is easy to read and understand.
Unfortunately, from the scientific point of view, it is difficult to evaluate the paper since very few details are provided on how experiments were run and how analyses were performed
For example, the authors reference some Chinese test methods and provide no details on how the tests were performed. In terms of analyses, apart from simple statistics, there is a one sentence mention of grey analysis without any further details.
The authors are referencing documents that can not be accessed and provide only one or two old references from more accessible references although there are many more other references in the subject area . I also have a problem when no equation is provided in a manuscript for a scientific journal .

ÉÏÃæÊÇÆÀÉóÒâ¼û¡£ ÇëÎÊ£¬Reviewer #1µÄµÚ5µãÒâ¼ûÊÇʲôÒâË¼ÄØ£¿

Reviewer #2µÄÒâ¼ûÄÜ·ñ°ïÖú·­ÒëÒ»ÏÂÂ𣿠Îҵķ­ÒëÈçÏ£¨´ó¸ÅÒâ˼£©£º

ÊÔÑé·½·¨¼°·ÖÎö·½·¨ËµµÄ²»¹»Ïêϸ¡£ÈçÖйú¹æ·¶Öеķ½·¨Ó¦¸Ã½éÉÜһϡ£´ËÍ⣬³ýÁËһЩ¼òµ¥µÄͳ¼Æ·ÖÎö£¬ÎÄÖÐÌáµ½Á˻ҹØÁª·ÖÎö£¬µ«Ã»ÓÐÈκεÄÏêϸÐÅÏ¢£¨ÊÇÈÃÎÒ¶ÔÕâ·½·¨¼òÒªµÄ½éÉÜÒ»ÏÂÂ𣿣©¡£
×÷Õ߲ο¼ÁËһЩËûÃÇËÑË÷²»µ½µÄÎÄÏ×£¨¿ÉÄÜÊÇÓÐһЩÊǹúÄÚµÄÆÚ¿¯ËüÃÇËѲ»µ½£¬»¹ÓÐһЩÊǹúÄÚµÄÑо¿±¨¸æ¡£Ñо¿±¨¸æÎÒÏëËûÃǿ϶¨ÊÇËѲ»µ½°É£¬ÎÒÓ¦¸ÃÔõô°ìÄØ£¿£©¡£¾¡¹ÜÔÚËûÃÇÄÜËÑË÷µ½µÄÎÄÏ×ÖÐÓкܶàÏà¹ØÎÄÏ×£¬µ«×÷ÕßÖ»²Î¿¼ÁËËûÃÇÄܲéµÃµ½µÄ¡¢ºÜÉÙ¡¢ºÜ¹ÅÀϵÄÎÄÏס£´ËÍ⣬ÔڿƼ¼ÂÛÎÄÖУ¬¿ÉÒÔûÓй«Ê½Â𣿣¨ÊÇÏ£ÍûÎÒÔÚÂÛÎÄÖÐÌṩһЩ¹«Ê½Â𣿣©

¿ÏÇë´ó¼ÒÖ¸µã£¡

[ Last edited by RoseAndy on 2011-2-25 at 20:17 ]
»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥

» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶

» ÇÀ½ð±ÒÀ²£¡»ØÌû¾Í¿ÉÒԵõ½:

²é¿´È«²¿É¢½ðÌù

ÒÑÔÄ   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

RoseAndy

¾èÖú¹ó±ö (ÕýʽдÊÖ)


ÒýÓûØÌû:
Originally posted by jlu_w at 2011-02-25 20:17:07:
²»ÊÇÏà¹Ø×¨Òµ  ÄÜ·ñÕâÑùÀí½â£¿
¹ØÓÚA testºÍCindexµÄÏà¹ØÎÊÌâÒѾ­ÓÐÁ˺ܶà˵Ã÷ÁË£¬C indexÄÜ·ñÌæ´ú TSRST test
µÄ½á¹û£¿
Éó¸åÈË2 ÊÇÏÓÄãÒýÓÃÁËÌ«¶àÖÐÎÄÎÄÏ×°É£¬»¹ÓÐһЩ±È½ÏÀϵÄÎÄÏ×£¬Õâ¸öµÄÈ·²»Ó¦¸Ã£¡»¹ÓÐʵ ...

¹ØÓÚA testºÍCindexµÄÏà¹ØÎÊÌâÒѾ­ÓÐÁ˺ܶà˵Ã÷ÁË  
ÄãµÄÒâ˼ÊÇ˵ ÒѾ­ÓкܶàÎÄÏ×ÔÚÌÖÂÛÕâ¸öÎÊÌâÁË£¿
3Â¥2011-02-25 20:21:11
ÒÑÔÄ   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
²é¿´È«²¿ 4 ¸ö»Ø´ð

jlu_w

ľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)


¡ï ¡ï ¡ï
RoseAndy(½ð±Ò+5): ллָµã£¡ 2011-02-25 20:22:37
Öí»á·É(½ð±Ò+3): ¸Ðл½»Á÷ 2011-02-25 20:56:08
²»ÊÇÏà¹Ø×¨Òµ  ÄÜ·ñÕâÑùÀí½â£¿
¹ØÓÚA testºÍCindexµÄÏà¹ØÎÊÌâÒѾ­ÓÐÁ˺ܶà˵Ã÷ÁË£¬C indexÄÜ·ñÌæ´ú TSRST test
µÄ½á¹û£¿
Éó¸åÈË2 ÊÇÏÓÄãÒýÓÃÁËÌ«¶àÖÐÎÄÎÄÏ×°É£¬»¹ÓÐһЩ±È½ÏÀϵÄÎÄÏ×£¬Õâ¸öµÄÈ·²»Ó¦¸Ã£¡»¹ÓÐʵÑé¾ßÌå²½ÖèʲôµÄÃ²ËÆÂ¥Ö÷˵µÄºÜ¼òµ¥ÄØ
2Â¥2011-02-25 20:17:07
ÒÑÔÄ   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

jlu_w

ľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)


ÒýÓûØÌû:
Originally posted by RoseAndy at 2011-02-25 20:21:11:
¹ØÓÚA testºÍCindexµÄÏà¹ØÎÊÌâÒѾ­ÓÐÁ˺ܶà˵Ã÷ÁË  
ÄãµÄÒâ˼ÊÇ˵ ÒѾ­ÓкܶàÎÄÏ×ÔÚÌÖÂÛÕâ¸öÎÊÌâÁË£¿

Ö»ÊÇ×ÖÃæÒâ˼  Èç¹û²»ÊÇÎÄÏ×¶àµÄ»°  ÊDz»ÊÇÂ¥Ö÷ÔÚÎÄÖÐÖØ¸´½éÉÜÁËÄØ£¿ ±ÈÈçͼºÍ±í¶¼ËµÃ÷¹ý´ËÀàÎÊÌâ
4Â¥2011-02-25 22:23:06
ÒÑÔÄ   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
×î¾ßÈËÆøÈÈÌûÍÆ¼ö [²é¿´È«²¿] ×÷Õß »Ø/¿´ ×îºó·¢±í
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¹¤¿Æ0856Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ãåÎö͡͡ 2026-03-21 4/200 2026-03-23 13:08 by ×íÔÚ·çÀï
[¿¼ÑÐ] 276Çóµ÷¼Á¡£ÓаëÄêµç³ØºÍ°ëÄê¸ß·Ö×Óʵϰ¾­Àú +8 ²ÄÁÏѧ257Çóµ÷¼Á 2026-03-23 9/450 2026-03-23 13:01 by ztnimte
[¿¼ÑÐ] 0703 µ÷¼Á +3 ÎÒ¿ÉÒÔÉϰ¶µÄ¶Ô 2026-03-16 6/300 2026-03-23 08:52 by ×íÔÚ·çÀï
[¿¼ÑÐ] 323Çóµ÷¼Á +6 ÍÝСͰ 2026-03-18 6/300 2026-03-23 00:29 by king123£¡
[¿¼ÑÐ] 328Çóµ÷¼Á£¬Ó¢ÓïÁù¼¶551£¬ÓпÆÑо­Àú +6 ÉúÎ﹤³Ìµ÷¼Á 2026-03-17 10/500 2026-03-22 20:22 by edmund7
[¿¼ÑÐ] 275Çóµ÷¼Á +6 shansx 2026-03-22 8/400 2026-03-22 15:27 by barlinike
[¿¼ÑÐ] Çóµ÷¼ÁԺУÐÅÏ¢ +6 CX 330 2026-03-21 6/300 2026-03-22 15:25 by ÎÞи¿É»÷111
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¿¼Ñе÷¼Á +4 À´ºÃÔËÀ´À´À´ 2026-03-21 4/200 2026-03-22 12:15 by ÐÇ¿ÕÐÇÔÂ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 286Çóµ÷¼Á +10 Faune 2026-03-21 10/500 2026-03-21 23:34 by 314126402
[¿¼ÑÐ] Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ÒªºÃºÃÎÞÁÄ 2026-03-21 4/200 2026-03-21 18:57 by ѧԱ8dgXkO
[¿¼ÑÐ] ²ÄÁÏÓ뻯¹¤£¨0856£©304Çó BÇø µ÷¼Á +3 Çñgl 2026-03-21 3/150 2026-03-21 13:47 by lature00
[¿¼ÑÐ] 070300»¯Ñ§319Çóµ÷¼Á +7 ½õÀð0909 2026-03-17 7/350 2026-03-21 03:46 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 332Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ydfyh 2026-03-17 4/200 2026-03-21 02:20 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] Çóµ÷¼Á +3 Ma_xt 2026-03-17 3/150 2026-03-21 02:05 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085700×ÊÔ´Óë»·¾³308Çóµ÷¼Á +12 īīĮ 2026-03-18 13/650 2026-03-21 01:42 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 290Çóµ÷¼Á +7 ^O^Ø¿ 2026-03-19 7/350 2026-03-20 21:43 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] Ò»Ö¾Ô¸Î÷ÄϽ»Í¨ ר˶ ²ÄÁÏ355 ±¾¿ÆË«·Ç Çóµ÷¼Á +5 Î÷ÄϽ»Í¨×¨²Ä355 2026-03-19 5/250 2026-03-20 21:10 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] Ò»Ö¾Ô¸Î÷°²½»Í¨´óѧ ѧ˶ 354Çóµ÷¼Á211»òÕß˫һÁ÷ +3 ÎÒÏëÒª¶ÁÑо¿Éú 2026-03-20 3/150 2026-03-20 20:13 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 086500 325 Çóµ÷¼Á +3 Áì´øÐ¡ÐÜ 2026-03-19 3/150 2026-03-20 18:38 by ¾¡Ë´Ò¢1
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¿¼Ñе÷¼Á +3 ä¿ya_~ 2026-03-17 5/250 2026-03-17 09:25 by Winj1e
ÐÅÏ¢Ìáʾ
ÇëÌî´¦ÀíÒâ¼û