| 查看: 455 | 回复: 2 | |||
[交流]
【求助】关于审稿意见
|
|
最近投了一篇小文章,审稿人提的问题不知道该怎么修改、回答,还请各位多多指教。 1) The water cluster and 1D tape formed through hydrogen bonding are claimed to be novel ‘to our best knowledge’, however no substantiation beyond this statement is given. A reference is made to the work of Motherwell and Infantes which dates back to 2002! Indeed, this systematic and detailed report only deals with water clusters in organic molecular crystals. It is not novel that water molecules hydrogen bond together to form clusters and it remains with the authors to prove the novelty of the arrangement reported here by adopting a similar approach of Motherwell. A systematic interrogation of the CSD needs to be done in order to prove novelty beyond doubt. If this cannot be done, then the novelty cannot be verified and the report is then little more than the structural report of a very simple coordination complex bearing a known ligand. 审稿人说是让证明新颖性,怎么证明啊?谢谢! 2)When describing the structure, some macro descriptions should be appeared, as the distance between the 1D water tapes and the 2D layers. 请问是什么意思?谢谢! |
» 猜你喜欢
这个水相反应有没有催化剂促进发生
已经有4人回复
Mn Me3TACN
已经有5人回复
无机化学论文润色/翻译怎么收费?
已经有175人回复
求助最新的CCDC数据库升级包
已经有0人回复
高中化学教师求助:配合物一水硫酸四氨合铜的紫外可见吸收光谱数据
已经有2人回复
ACS omega,返修返回去目前为in peer review,求助进度问题
已经有4人回复
南开大学化学学院招收电催化方向2027级博士生、博士后
已经有27人回复
单晶解析,可协助单晶解析、精修、CIF 修正、错误排查
已经有0人回复
深圳大学化学与环境工程学院超分子团队招收2027级申请-考核制博士生
已经有6人回复
湘潭大学高平课题组招收2027届化学博士生
已经有5人回复
2楼2010-12-24 15:47:05
3楼2011-01-11 12:47:57










回复此楼
10