24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

blueesky

铁杆木虫 (著名写手)

应助: 13 (小学生)
金币: 6782.6
散金: 1032
红花: 5
帖子: 1607
在线: 1027小时
虫号: 707598
注册: 2009-02-24
专业: 零件加工制造

[交流] 第二篇Acta Materialia_Minor Revision 已有35人参与

09年12月27日投稿Acta Materialia 一篇，整个过程比较快
29日主编就送审了，今年3月15日收到审稿意见，审稿人的意见很好，几个小错误，16日返回，17日就接收了。

Editor's/Reviewer's comments:

It is a paper with useful scientific information on a process which is in production use in aerospace companies like GE for more than a decade. *******. There a few minor clarifications and corrections needed. They are as follows.
1) Page 5: ****
2)Page 7: Figure 4 shows ***
3) Page 8: ****

Overall it is sound paper and should be accepted with minor modification.

第二篇是4月3日投稿，4月15日 Under Review，6月3日收到审稿意见

Ref.: Ms. No. A-10-***

Acta Materialia

Dear Dr. *,

I have now received an independent review of your manuscript. Overall, it is a very favorable review, however, the referee has made optional suggestions for you to revise the paper. See below review.

If you will address these comments in your revised paper, I shall be pleased to consider your manuscript for publication in Acta Materialia. Although the publisher has a copy editor, when the correstions are substantial it is in your best interest to have the paper edited locally before sending it to the publisher.

[/url]

Thank you.

Yours sincerely,

Subhash Mahajan
Acta Materialia

Editor's/Reviewer's comments:

**************************

Overall, this is a well written paper, with detailed presentation of the microstructure *********makes this an important collection that will be widely used.

There are minor syntax-type corrections that will need to be made, which I assume will be picked up during final editing. Apart, from that, the paper is acceptable in its present form.

[ Last edited by blueesky on 2010-6-3 at 09:24 ]

回复此楼