24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

梦涵秋枫

银虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 387.3
散金: 16
帖子: 170
在线: 18.3小时
虫号: 835385
注册: 2009-08-27
性别: MM
专业: 化学反应工程

[交流] 编辑给了修改的意见，但是杂志上显示的状态依然是Awaiting assignment。纳闷？？？已有4人参与

本人4月19投了一篇文章到Adsorption Science and Technology 这篇杂志上，5月6号也就是今天编辑就给了一位审稿人的意见并要求修改。另外本人同实验室的一位同学去年也投了这篇杂志，但是他等了四五个月才有了修改的消息，不过最后接受了。
我奇怪的是虽然编辑给了修改的意见，但是杂志上显示的状态依然是Awaiting assignment。纳闷？？？大家帮忙参考参考，也给给意见吧！我该去问问编辑怎么回事儿吗？
顺便附上编辑给的意见吧：

Dear Dr. Xu:

Reviewers have now commented on your paper, as seen below. You will see that they are advising that you revise your manuscript.
If you are prepared to undertake the work required, I would be pleased to reconsider your manuscript. Please give a careful consideration
to the criticisms raised. All of them should be taken into account in a revised version of your manuscript.

Please send your revised manuscript, together with an itemized letter answering all the comments made and describing all changes
made in response, or the reason why no change should be made. In any case your manuscript might need a second review.

regards,

Dr. Erich A. Muller

Editor  - Adsorption Science and Technology

Home page:  http://www.multi-science.co.uk/adsorpt.htm

Contents:  http://multi-science.metapress.com/content/121490/

___________

Reviewer A

In this paper, TiO2-surface-imprinted polymer showed imprinting effect and was applied to the adsorption of organosulfur compounds like BT, DBT, 4-MDBT and 4,6-DMDBT. It is proved that D-MIP/TiO2 has better adsorption performance than the D-NIP/TiO2, D-CIP and TiO2. Moreover, adsorption of DBT on D-MIP/TiO2 is multilayer adsorption and is endothermic in nature. This technique seems to be feasible for removal of organosulfur compounds especially bulky molecules.

This paper can be published after the revision of following suggestions/changes:

1-    What are the physical properties (e.g. surface area, porosity, crystallinity etc.) of the nano-TiO2 used? Why did you choose the rutile and not the anatase phase TiO2? As TiO2 has a major role here, so it would be useful to include the details mentioned above.
2-    In Eq. (3) /”TiO2” is misspelled, correct it.
3-    Section 3.1: There is no reference in the text, report the concerned reference at the proper place.
4-    Did you check the adsorption behavior at the temperatures higher than 318 K and lower than 288 K (shown in Fig. 3), what is the trend?
5-    Table 5, the imprinting factors for competitive assays data for 4-MDBT and 4,6-DMDBT is not reported?

[ Last edited by 梦涵秋枫 on 2010-5-6 at 16:16 ]

回复此楼