| 查看: 2857 | 回复: 36 | |||
phoenix810木虫 (小有名气)
|
[交流]
ACS 投稿返回意见交流（散金币） 已有36人参与
|
|
投稿到ACS Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research今天收到审稿意见如下: reviewer1: Summary Recommendation: Publishable paper; requires substantial revisions and shortening as indicated and then publish as a short note (see detailed comment b below). No re-review recommended. 貌似叫我缩写。最后一句话什么意思？改完之后不用再审了？ Recommendation: The authors use the single objective particle swarm algorithm (PSA) of Shi and Eberhart to optimize a single plate-fin heat exchanger. I have reservations on this ms., but still recommend its publication as a short note (but only after a substantial re-writing and shortening as described below). Detailed Comments: a) Page 2: The authors mention that though several papers exist on the design of heat exchangers (HXs), nothing much is available on their optimization [“... do not consist of any optimization strategies that are needed …”]. This is just NOT true. See, for example: Agarwal, A. and Gupta, S. K., Jumping Gene Adaptations of NSGA-II and Their Use in the Multi-objective Optimal Design of Shell and Tube Heat Exchangers, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 86, 123-139 (2008). A. Jiminez et al., Indus. Eng. Chem. Res., recent issue The authors need to look at papers in Chemical Engineering journals and expand their literature survey to beyond the restricted confines of Mechanical Engineering. In fact, a considerable amount of optimization using more than a single objective function has also been reported, as also the multi-objective optimization (MOO) of Heat Exchanger networks (the heuristic pinch algorithm, now using multi-objective GA), etc. The authors seem to be blissfully unaware of all this work in the literature of heat exchanger optimization. b) I believe that the days of optimizing simple problems involving only a single objective function are long over. The two articles mentioned above use the very detailed Bell-Delaware method to estimate/size the HX (though not for plate-fin HXs), and then to optimize it using more than one objective function (multi-objective optimization, MOO). Indeed, the authors talk a bit about the possibility of a Pareto set of non-dominated (equally good or optimal) solutions on page 14 of their ms., without realizing that this reflects two points of a Pareto set for a two-objective function problem, and MOO algorithms can be used to study this more effectively. Hence, I find this ms. far too elementary for publication in IECRes, except as a short note. c) Several references have ‘et al.’ This is possibly not acceptable to a journal, I believe, and all authors need be mentioned. d) The language needs substantial improvement. reviewer2: Comments to the Author To demonstrate the improvement proposed, authors should compare their results against PSO methodologies proposed by others. In this paper, it seems that the convergence is achieved by fixed number of evaluations. Can this guarantee optimum for any problem? Conclusion of the paper should be improved to account physical significance of the problem. 审稿人2好像没什么意见，有没有人能把Can this guarantee optimum for any problem? 这句话什么意思翻译看看啊？ 请大家帮忙看看，多谢了！ PS:文章修好后，一个礼拜顺利录用，感谢大家无私的帮助！  [ Last edited by phoenix810 on 2010-5-6 at 16:26 ] |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
学硕274求调剂
已经有11人回复
-
一志愿郑大材料工程290求调剂
已经有12人回复
-
环境工程 085701，267求调剂
已经有8人回复
-
083000学硕274求调剂
已经有10人回复
-
一志愿085600中科院宁波所276分求调剂
已经有4人回复
-
材料专业申博
已经有3人回复
-
307求调剂
已经有20人回复
-
285求调剂
已经有8人回复
-
材料与化工（0856）304求B区调剂
已经有8人回复
-
370求调剂
已经有3人回复
» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:
- RSC和ACS的审稿意见结果什么的是共享的吗？？被拒后重投有什么经验？？
已经有10人回复
- ACS投稿 三个审稿人一个拒稿 拒稿的那个人提出的东西也要回答吗？
已经有23人回复
- 投到ACS旗下一个的杂志的回信意见
已经有31人回复
- 投JAP还是ACS Appl Mater&Interface？大家积极交流啊！
已经有17人回复
- 【求助】有劳虫友高手帮忙看看acs审稿意见，多谢！
已经有5人回复
- ACS编辑提的意见，看不太懂，求高人指点一下
已经有6人回复
- ACS投了一篇，3个多月了，这是个什么状态啊，编辑你能回个信么
已经有16人回复
- 【有奖活动】我的投稿经历(活动已更新)
已经有17人回复
- 加个新问题 ACS applied materials & interfaces 达审稿人意见求助
已经有13人回复
- 【交流】acs投稿
已经有3人回复
2楼2010-04-25 22:20:47
yccycc
木虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 17 (小学生)
- 金币: 1921.7
- 散金: 10
- 红花: 4
- 帖子: 1076
- 在线: 64.2小时
- 虫号: 478326
- 注册: 2007-12-14
- 专业: 无机非金属类光电信息与功
3楼2010-04-26 04:51:28
★
phoenix810(金币+1):谢谢参与
phoenix810(金币+1):谢谢参与
| 恭喜 |
4楼2010-04-26 07:05:23
★
phoenix810(金币+1):谢谢参与
phoenix810(金币+1):谢谢参与
恭喜 |
5楼2010-04-26 07:13:41
youth0826
至尊木虫 (著名写手)
weibo.com/138147022
- 应助: 172 (高中生)
- 金币: 10458.4
- 散金: 145
- 红花: 4
- 帖子: 1726
- 在线: 149.4小时
- 虫号: 707170
- 注册: 2009-02-23
- 专业: 模式识别
6楼2010-04-26 07:37:20
yqchen8508
银虫 (正式写手)
- 应助: 19 (小学生)
- 金币: 1715.7
- 散金: 403
- 红花: 6
- 帖子: 381
- 在线: 208.3小时
- 虫号: 848651
- 注册: 2009-09-15
- 专业: 岩土与基础工程
7楼2010-04-26 07:44:02
wellyy2005
至尊木虫 (文坛精英)
s
- SEPI: 5
- 应助: 911 (博后)
- 贵宾: 0.81
- 金币: 34048.3
- 散金: 7213
- 红花: 74
- 沙发: 32
- 帖子: 15755
- 在线: 1752.8小时
- 虫号: 498546
- 注册: 2008-02-04
- 专业: 肿瘤综合治疗
8楼2010-04-26 07:46:47
jiangkq
铁杆木虫 (正式写手)
- 应助: 0 (幼儿园)
- 金币: 13001.2
- 帖子: 523
- 在线: 86.5小时
- 虫号: 950057
- 注册: 2010-01-28
- 专业: 计算机科学的基础理论
9楼2010-04-26 07:52:57
jyzcd
铁杆木虫 (知名作家)
负责人
- 应助: 18 (小学生)
- 金币: 10154.4
- 散金: 1262
- 红花: 3
- 帖子: 9973
- 在线: 160.9小时
- 虫号: 94158
- 注册: 2005-09-26
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 粉末冶金与粉体工程
10楼2010-04-26 08:01:56
