24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

luobin13579

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 89.4
散金: 35
红花: 1
帖子: 54
在线: 17.6小时
虫号: 966613
注册: 2010-03-10
性别: GG
专业: 零件成形制造

[交流] 会议终稿我应该提交初稿，还是修改稿。已有3人参与

呵呵，我是一个硕士生，由于课题需要，老师要求投国际会议，EI论文，看了一大堆文献后（辛苦啊），终于找到一个创新点，做了实验，整理数据。得了一篇英文论文，找了相关联的会议（ICIA）就投了过去，居然得了。惊喜啊！大家帮我看看。

Reviewer 1
============================================================================
Reviewer's Scores
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Originality of Concept: Good
   Relevance of Applications: Fair
         Technical Soundness: Good
      Thoroughness of Results: Good
      Importance of Results: Good
      Clarity of Presentation: Good
               Recommendation: Accept
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Detailed Comments
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GP surrogate model is adopted to reduce warpage of injection molding parts. Theoretical analysis and experiment results show that the optimization method is efficient for reducing warpage. The paper is clear and organized well.
============================================================================
Reviewer 2
============================================================================
Reviewer's Scores
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Originality of Concept: Very Good
   Relevance of Applications: Very Good
         Technical Soundness: Good
      Thoroughness of Results: Good
      Importance of Results: Good
      Clarity of Presentation: Good
               Recommendation: Definitely Accept
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Detailed Comments
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
In this paper, an adaptive optimization method using Gaussian process surrogate model is developed to minimize warpage of injection molding parts. An enhanced probability improvement selection criterion is proposed based on Gaussian process surrogate model. Under the new criterion, the surrogate model can find the global optima faster. The simulation results show the efficiency of this method. The paper is well organized and the result is interesting.
The author name of Ref. [11] is not correct.
============================================================================
想问一下各位大虫，我投稿后也对论文也做了大修改，比之前的更完善，那我要不要把后面的修改版提交过去呢？呵呵，我还有个私心，我们老板还希望把我的点子投SCI期刊，我就希望把修改稿投期刊，而会议论文就用原来投的初稿。
大家帮忙指点一下。

[ Last edited by luobin13579 on 2010-4-8 at 11:25 ]

回复此楼