24小时热门版块排行榜    

Znn3bq.jpeg
查看: 1785  |  回复: 22
当前主题已经存档。

chenfire

木虫 (著名写手)

[交流] 有意思的经历——遭遇审稿人“寻仇”

5月份投的一篇文章,被一个审稿人拒稿后仍被编辑接收并且发表了。
详情:http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=1421078
现在新文章又落到了他手上,他对新文章倒是没意见,但对旧文章仍然耿耿于怀,以下是他的审稿意见:


This manuscript presents more experimental results of XXXX. The authors just published a communication in XXXX. I was also a reviewer for that paper. My main comment is that the manuscript should include more experimental data by XXXX, and should be changed to a full paper for publication. It is obvious that the first paper was accepted for publication as a communication without taking my comments seriously. This second paper demonstrates additional data in the same topic by changing the experimental conditions, such as XXXX. Some parts of the paper have been already shown in the first paper, e.g. Fig. 7(a) and the corresponding text.

The most important problem is that these two papers XXXX. In their first paper, they concluded XXXX. To confirm this conclusion, I suggested that some experiments should be performed. They did not do as I suggested. Now they must have done some more experiments and present a new conclusion. This new statement seems to be more reasonable. However, the authors should discuss the different models presented in their own papers. I would like to see whether the previous conclusion is still correct. If not, please tell us why?   

Since the paper contains some new results (as far as I understand), I suggest it can be accepted for publication. A few revisions should be considered by the authors:

后面提了三个小问题:1, 参考文献2引用有问题。 2,一个图的说明要详细点。3,某个方面的参考文献要加多几篇。


上一篇文章他提出来的问题我们已经详细解释过了,编辑看后同意我们的观点,直接接收了文章,没把回复意见给他看,所以他至今还没跟我们交流过。都已经过了好几个月了,老外的科研态度真是严肃、执着啊!太佩服了!

[ Last edited by chenfire on 2009-10-25 at 14:45 ]
回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

非淡泊无以明志,非宁静无以致远
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
2楼2009-10-25 14:55:33
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

hfut1879

至尊木虫 (文坛精英)


小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包,谢谢回帖交流
呵呵这种情况还算是比较正常的啊
3楼2009-10-25 15:22:05
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

wuss2005

木虫 (著名写手)

这种情况还算是比较正常的啊
4楼2009-10-25 15:28:26
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

shuxuei

铁杆木虫 (著名写手)

引用回帖:
Originally posted by chenfire at 2009-10-25 14:41:
5月份投的一篇文章,被一个审稿人拒稿后仍被编辑接收并且发表了。
详情:http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=1421078
现在新文章又落到了他手上,他对新文章倒是没意见,但对旧文章仍然耿耿于 ...

正常情况!做学问确实要严谨啊!
5楼2009-10-25 16:11:46
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

qilu_qi

金虫 (著名写手)

呵呵怎么有到他的手上了啊,审搞人太少了把
6楼2009-10-25 16:13:53
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

jjyyldxm

铜虫 (正式写手)


小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包,谢谢回帖交流
人家也可以,没有把你第2篇拒绝掉,算大气的了
7楼2009-10-25 20:10:11
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

marineman

至尊木虫 (知名作家)

爱八卦爱生活


小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包,谢谢回帖交流
审稿人确实很认真。希望你的这篇能接受。
8楼2009-10-25 20:22:31
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

chenfire

木虫 (著名写手)

引用回帖:
Originally posted by marineman at 2009-10-25 20:22:
审稿人确实很认真。希望你的这篇能接受。

谢谢楼上,呵呵
非淡泊无以明志,非宁静无以致远
9楼2009-10-25 20:27:54
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

zllee77

木虫 (正式写手)

老外就是认真。值得钦佩!!
10楼2009-10-25 20:38:00
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 chenfire 的主题更新
普通表情 高级回复 (可上传附件)
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[考研] 求调剂 +6 archer.. 2026-04-09 8/400 2026-04-11 10:55 by zhq0425
[考研] 化工调剂求导师收留!一志愿失利,踏实肯干,有植物提取科研经历 +17 yzyzx 2026-04-09 18/900 2026-04-11 10:48 by 环化材-小生
[考研] 293求调剂 +5 勇远库爱314 2026-04-06 5/250 2026-04-11 09:44 by zhq0425
[考研] 085410 273求调剂 +3 X1999 2026-04-09 3/150 2026-04-11 09:22 by 猪会飞
[考研] 342电子信息专硕求调剂 +9 你让我怎么荔枝 2026-04-10 10/500 2026-04-11 08:33 by zhq0425
[考研] 070300化学学硕311分求调剂 +17 梁富贵险中求 2026-04-04 19/950 2026-04-11 00:29 by wangjihu
[考研] 278求调剂 +27 范婷娜 2026-04-07 31/1550 2026-04-09 20:49 by zhouxiaoyu
[考研] 求调剂希望还是希望在山河四省附近 +3 快乐的小白鸽 2026-04-05 3/150 2026-04-09 17:36 by wp06
[考研] 一志愿厦大生物学332求调剂 +10 池池池池池池 2026-04-08 10/500 2026-04-09 17:10 by 独醉梦孤城
[考研] 材料调剂 +14 一样YWY 2026-04-06 14/700 2026-04-08 23:00 by 猪会飞
[考研] 307分材料专业求调剂 +12 Hll胡 2026-04-05 12/600 2026-04-08 16:33 by luoyongfeng
[考研] 287求调剂 +6 Fnhc 2026-04-07 6/300 2026-04-08 10:05 by xingguangj
[考研] 材料工程专业日语生求调剂 +9 111623 2026-04-07 9/450 2026-04-07 23:31 by 一只好果子?
[考研] 材料求调剂 +18 一样YWY 2026-04-05 18/900 2026-04-07 15:49 by dxlg
[考研] 319分085702安全工程求调剂 +6 rious 2026-04-05 6/300 2026-04-07 09:42 by jp9609
[考研] 312求调剂 +4 LR6 2026-04-06 4/200 2026-04-07 08:42 by jp9609
[考研] 287分求调剂 有专利国奖一志愿哈工大085406 +6 白易辰 2026-04-06 7/350 2026-04-06 22:46 by 875465
[考研] 307求调剂 +3 所念及所望 2026-04-06 3/150 2026-04-06 17:30 by 土木硕士招生
[考研] 285求调剂 +8 AZMK 2026-04-04 11/550 2026-04-06 13:56 by BruceLiu320
[考研] 工科277分求调剂材料 +8 上了上了上哦 2026-04-05 9/450 2026-04-05 13:05 by wwytracy
信息提示
请填处理意见