| 查看: 1087 | 回复: 7 | |||
[交流]
2个审稿人意见有点不一致。请大伙给点思路，我应该怎么修改。
|
|||
|
大家好，小弟刚投了一个2区sci论文，编辑给大修意见，2个审稿人意见有点不一致。请大伙给点思路，我应该怎么修改。 -Reviewer 1 - The authors examine the effect on magnetic lens properties of modifying the shape of the corners of the yoke. Not surprisingly, a small improvement is found. However, this result does not justify a full-length paper, a short note would be sufficient. Much of the introduction is very well known and it is not always accurate. Thus Glaser published his bell-shaped field before his book appeared in 1952. One major contribution to lens design is missing, "Practical lens design" by W.D. Riecke, in 'Magnetic Electron Lenses' (P.W. Hawkes, ed., Springer 1982). I therefore recommend that the authors be encouraged to produce a much shorter paper or a conference abstract, giving only the results of their calculations. -Reviewer 2 What reviewer suggests to the authors are the following. This paper deals about an analysis method of magnetically saturated electron lenses without using a commercial software. This is a significant point to be published in Ultramicroscopy. Historically, analytical methods for design electron lenses are changed to numerical methods, because analytical method cannot treat the magnetically saturated lenses. So that, if the analytical method can treat the magnetically saturated lenses, it can come back. An advantage of the analytical method is free. Simulation software are now commercially available but not free. So that, at present, only the people working on the lens design, can analyze electron lenses and people who have an interest but have no commercial software cannot do analyze electron lenses. So that, it is very useful for usual people who can join a design of electron lens following this paper. However, authors don’t describe about things which are not their original points but necessary things what reader want to do a similar calculation following this paper. This is quite usual thing because Ultramicroscopy is an original Journal. However, if a reader wants to do make a similar calculation following this paper, he or she must check other papers referenced in this paper about already known things. This must be uninterest work and need a lot of time. So that, reviewer recommends the authors to write all the things necessary for the analysis should be written within this paper. Original things should be written in main pages and already known things in Appendix. Then, reader can do analyze about their lenses only reading your paper without checking some paper or buy a commercial software. |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
铟锡化合物半导体材料与器件团队[推介]
+3/145
-
延安大学化学与化工学院接收化学专业调剂生（工科、理学均可调剂）
+5/145
-
浙江农林大学环境与资源学院/碳中和学院 招收调剂生，学硕1名、专硕2名
+1/97
-
广西师范大学-王艳课题组2026年招收药学学硕 、生物与医药专硕调剂生
+1/86
-
安徽宿州学院 085600材料与化工(专业学位) 2026年研究生招生调剂信息
+1/85
-
高分子材料 调剂——材料-化学方向优先
+1/69
-
2026 硕士研究生调剂｜河南工业大学化学化工学院名额开放
+2/58
-
山东青岛-导师招生
+1/51
-
招聘 博士教师有编制 ，材料加工工程，金属材料方向 月薪1.8W起， 地点陕西渭南
+1/30
-
中国石油大学（北京）理学院2026年硕士研究生接收调剂生：物理、化学、材料等
+1/12
-
齐齐哈尔大学李莉课题组诚招2026级考研调剂生（学硕和专硕）
+1/7
-
齐齐哈尔大学李莉课题组诚招2026级考研调剂生（学硕和专硕）
+1/7
-
26年申博自荐-计算机视觉
+1/6
-
【调剂上岸】985联合培养！1007/1055/08/07等，不限专业，想联培的速来！
+1/5
-
济南大学2026年硕士研究生招生预调剂公告
+1/4
-
赣南师范大学郭维课题组招收化学类、药学类、材料类学硕、专硕考研调剂同学
+1/3
-
大连工业大学考研调剂
+1/3
-
齐齐哈尔大学化学与化学工程学院招收专硕调剂
+1/2
-
大湾区大学李军课题组招收生物信息学、人工智能方向博士后
+1/2
-
河南城建学院市政与环境工程学院2026年硕士研究生接收调剂公告
+1/1
3楼2018-05-31 16:04:21
5楼2018-05-31 16:23:50
6楼2018-05-31 16:24:31
简单回复
润色论文2楼
2018-05-31 15:58
回复
40428643(金币+1): 谢谢参与
顶 发自小木虫IOS客户端
loyunpo4楼
2018-05-31 16:08
回复
40428643(金币+1): 谢谢参与
好 发自小木虫Android客户端
奋斗0梦7楼
2018-05-31 16:26
回复
40428643(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
物理所院士8楼
2018-05-31 16:31
回复
40428643(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福 发自小木虫Android客户端
