24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者abcsk将赠送您 4 个金币

abcsk

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 110.1
散金: 68
红花: 1
帖子: 201
在线: 36小时
虫号: 2158035
注册: 2012-11-30
专业: 微观经济学

[求助] 请帮忙看看审稿人的意思已有1人参与

我投稿给了一个还可以的期刊，被拒稿了，但是审稿人给了一些意见，然后助理编辑根据审稿人的意见又给了我下面的意见，我有两点不大懂如何处理：
第一，他说我的文章基于一系列非常强的假设。这是不是表明我的假设有问题？
第二，他说我是使用了一个非常程式化的框架(stylized frameword)研究了一个非常特殊的问题。是不是我使用的这个程式化的框架过于程式化？

“I read your paper carefully and with interest. I think that you study an interesting issue for which there is not much that have been done in the literature before. I also think that the level of interest in the profession is high (and increasing) when it comes to studying the financial system in China. Your paper is a contribution in that direction and I think that is a valuable thing.

Having said that, let me also say that I think you are studying a very particular regulation using a very stylized framework and relying on a set of very strong assumptions. The referee hints at various directions in which you could move the analysis to try to make your results more general and robust.”

谢谢。

回复此楼