| 查看: 12814 | 回复: 13 | |||
[交流]
energies这个期刊有人投过没？ 意见回来了，两个审稿人，大家看看希望大不？ 已有9人参与
|
|||
|
第一个审稿人： English language and style ( ) Extensive editing of English language and style required (x) Moderate English changes required ( ) English language and style are fine/minor spell check required ( ) I don't feel qualified to judge about the English language and style Yes Can be improved Must be improved Not applicable Does the introduction provide sufficient background and include all relevant references? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Is the research design appropriate? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Are the methods adequately described? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Are the results clearly presented? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Are the conclusions supported by the results? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Comments and Suggestions for Authors 1) The article concerns a well-known method used in assessment of quality of paper-oil insualtion of transformers - FDS. The title indicates that the authors focused their work only on fundamental studies without deep analysis of the special factors which are developed by the authors in order to improve the FDS method. From this point of view I suggest to consider another title of the paper - more proper to the studies presented. 2) I have also a lot of doubts in relation to the Abstract. The presented conclusions from the experimental stuides are very obvious (well-known in the literature) so the authors should mention this fact. This is not a novelity which range of frequency in FDS method is responsible for which effect in paper-oil insulation. The rest of the abstract may be accepted. 3) In general the first part of the paper (Section 3.1) brings no novelity and could be presented in more limited range. I suggest to point out, in presentation of conclusions from this part of the studies, that the authors' observations are in accordance to the knowledge in the field of FDS method. You can relate your studies to the important documents in this field like: Cigre Brochure no 349: Moisture equilibrium and moisture migration within transformer insulation systems, June 2008 and Cigre Brochure no 414: Dielectric Response Diagnoses For Transformer Windings, April 2010 Minor comments: In formula (2) epsilon prim and epsilon bis are introduced but they are not described. It is obvious what they mean but for non-profesional readers it must be clearly explained. Section 2.2: Use three-electrode system rather than three electrode (with space between three and electrode) The sentence starting from "Then, in order to prevent..." is really difficult to understand. Please rewrite it. The sentence starting from "The instrument ...": use "Analyzer of ..." Section 3: What does it mean that oil and paper were set to 20:1 ratio? Please present this aspect more clearly. Use days not abbreviation "d" in description of aging days in the text. The sentence starting from :The moisture content of ..." is not gramathical. Section 3.3 / 3.3.1 3.3.2 - there are no capitals in the in titles of Sections Use "Table presents..." rather than "Table is..." (It is not gramathically corrected) In general there are some typos and grammar. Please read the text of the article carefully and correct them. 第二个审稿人： English language and style ( ) Extensive editing of English language and style required ( ) Moderate English changes required (x) English language and style are fine/minor spell check required ( ) I don't feel qualified to judge about the English language and style Yes Can be improved Must be improved Not applicable Does the introduction provide sufficient background and include all relevant references? ( ) ( ) (x) ( ) Is the research design appropriate? ( ) (x) ( ) ( ) Are the methods adequately described? (x) ( ) ( ) ( ) Are the results clearly presented? (x) ( ) ( ) ( ) Are the conclusions supported by the results? (x) ( ) ( ) ( ) Comments and Suggestions for Authors Dear authors, I would like to congratulate you for a very good paper. I recommend the paper for publication. However, I have several comments and suggestions that I consider of interest for improving the paper: I kindly suggest to detail what are terms such as Sm, SPD, gamma and phi in the abstract although you have mentioned them in the body text. Besides, could you explain more in detail this sentence "could eliminate the internal influence between moisture and aging degree." in the abstract? I consider that the introduction should be improved and additional papers should be discussed comparing your research with more previous ones. For example, which are the main differences between your work and others such as: "Field experiences with measurements of dielectric response in frequency domain for power transformer diagnostics," in IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 681-688, April 2006. doi: 10.1109/TPWRD.2005.861231 Regarding "the remaining life of the transformer largely depends on the insulation status of ol-paper" why not to talk about partial discharges and to include references from mdpi and other journals, not only about partial discharges, but also regarding remaining life of power transformers, statistical data, etc. About your sentence "The aging degree of oil paper insulation will directly determine the service life of the transformer, when the aging degree reaches to a certain extent, the transformer insulation will be completely ineffective." Why not to talk about breakdown and its consequences? Due to you are analyzing the combined effect of moisture and aging, you must compare your proposal with others more in details such as those mentioned below and/or others: "A moisture-in-oil model for power transformer monitoring - Part I: Theoretical foundation," in IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 1417-1422, April 2005. doi: 10.1109/TPWRD.2004.832366 "Diffusion coefficient in transformer pressboard insulation part 2: mineral oil impregnated," in IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 394-402, February 2014. "Determination of moisture diffusion coefficient for oil-impregnated Kraft-paper insulation, International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems, Volume 53, December 2013, Pages 279-286, ISSN 0142-0615, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijepes.2013.05.011. (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0142061513002032) MC should be defined in Table 2 and the rest of terms such as A0 should be referenced as samples in the text. When you are using low-frequency and high-frequency, please describe in a table which ranges of frequencies correspond with these bands, due to in i.e. radio spectrum, it refers to very different ranges. Discuss more in detail the sentence "therefore, in evaluating aging degree and moisture content, the assessment method can not only take individual factor into account and ignore the impact between the two." Minor comments Please, include all units for parameters in all Equations oil-paper instead oil paper high-frequency instead high frequency high-level Equation instead equation or formula Fourier instead fourier check the spelling: the tanδ curve mainly affect by moisture content, while has a unique (an) 3.3.2. (A)ging When you refers to a section, such as 3.1.1 or 3.2 please write "section 3.1.1" |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
2026年8月25日国自然放榜前突然收到列入评审专家邮件，有关系吗？
已经有19人回复
-
售SCI一区T0P文章，我:8.O.55.1.O.5.4,科目全,可+急
已经有3人回复
-
今天务委会开完了，明天出结果吗
已经有21人回复
-
在坚冰还盖着北海的时候，我看到了怒放的梅花。
已经有9人回复
-
明天应该可查了！？
已经有6人回复
-
有没有大神帮我看看基金代码
已经有10人回复
-
放榜前的不淡定
已经有19人回复
-
某些机构，以效率低为荣，以效率低作为存在感
已经有10人回复
-
2026国自然函评费到账
已经有23人回复
-
今日不放榜？网传国自然预计 8 月 27 日可查结果
已经有22人回复
lito7989
木虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 36 (小学生)
- 金币: 5114.7
- 散金: 1254
- 红花: 7
- 帖子: 1092
- 在线: 192.3小时
- 虫号: 2644436
- 注册: 2013-09-10
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 机械动力学
★ ★ ★
小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包，谢谢回帖
liouzhan654: 金币+2, 感谢交流 2017-06-11 21:25:32
小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包，谢谢回帖
liouzhan654: 金币+2, 感谢交流 2017-06-11 21:25:32
|
逐条回答，逻辑要清楚，有理有据，就能中，给修就是给机会！ 发自小木虫Android客户端 |
2楼2017-06-11 17:05:56
3楼2017-06-11 17:34:49
13楼2018-04-10 08:46:16
4楼2017-06-11 20:35:10
5楼2017-06-11 20:54:50
6楼2017-06-22 09:11:04
7楼2017-06-22 09:39:54
8楼2017-07-08 23:56:51
xiaohuli860
金虫 (小有名气)
- 应助: 0 (幼儿园)
- 金币: 1337
- 散金: 25
- 红花: 1
- 帖子: 157
- 在线: 137.6小时
- 虫号: 1379141
- 注册: 2011-08-25
- 性别: MM
- 专业: 预防医学其他科学问题
9楼2017-08-02 10:01:33
10楼2017-08-02 15:15:23
28