| 查看: 1702 | 回复: 5 | ||
smallbug2000木虫 (著名写手)
|
[求助]
小修论文还需要加比较实验吗？已有2人参与
|
|
投稿到一个低因子计算机方面的SCI期刊，投稿类型为letter，历时一年审稿结果为minor revision。审稿意见如下，一个审稿人，整体评价说如果加入最新论文比较可能更好。但是在修改意见并未提到。请教下：这种情况是否要加入比较实验？谢谢啦！ Reviewer #1: The paper brings a 3D pose tracking solution based on estimation of the 3D appearance models eliminating the need for hand-estimated models. The manuscript is well organized and presents good English quality. Also, the overall presentation is good (formatting, pictures, pseudo-algorithms). Authors present a strong motivation and state-of-the-art revision. In the following, a technical description of the solution is presented. It sounds clear and adequate for replication. The paper is dense and longer discussion - specially Section 2 - would be desirable. However, this is understandable in the case of a letter paper. Qualitative and quantitative results are presented and compared against related works. The results are promising and, for most scenarios, outperform the related works. Comparing against more recent solutions (2012 or later) would increase the paper impact. Summarizing, the paper is well presented and brings strong content. In my opinion, it is worth for publication as a letter paper. Minor: Avoid imprecise statements such as: "Pick a modest value for λ, say λ= 0:001;" What "statistical results" mean in: "Statistical results show that our proposed..."? Is it an average over all experiments? |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
职称评审没过，求安慰
已经有21人回复
-
垃圾破二本职称评审标准
已经有15人回复
-
投稿Elsevier的Neoplasia杂志，到最后选publishing options时页面空白，不能完成投稿
已经有20人回复
-
EST投稿状态问题
已经有7人回复
-
毕业后当辅导员了，天天各种学生超烦
已经有4人回复
-
聘U V热熔胶研究人员
已经有10人回复
-
求助文献
已经有3人回复
-
投稿返修后收到这样的回复，还有希望吗
已经有8人回复
-
三无产品还有机会吗
已经有6人回复
» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:
- SCI投稿过程总结、投稿状态解析、拒稿后对策及接受后期相关问答
已经有142人回复
- 大家快来看，关于decision letter中的comments from Editorial Committe
已经有10人回复
- 美国博后第一篇文章背后的故事
已经有46人回复
boy1234
木虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 147 (高中生)
- 金币: 3970.4
- 散金: 225
- 红花: 28
- 帖子: 1498
- 在线: 381.5小时
- 虫号: 4442589
- 注册: 2016-02-27
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 传动机械学
2楼2017-05-11 09:57:24
smallbug2000
木虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 13 (小学生)
- 金币: 2299.8
- 散金: 1794
- 红花: 17
- 帖子: 1239
- 在线: 781.9小时
- 虫号: 434011
- 注册: 2007-08-18
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 计算机应用技术
3楼2017-05-11 10:11:21
smallbug2000
木虫 (著名写手)
- 应助: 13 (小学生)
- 金币: 2299.8
- 散金: 1794
- 红花: 17
- 帖子: 1239
- 在线: 781.9小时
- 虫号: 434011
- 注册: 2007-08-18
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 计算机应用技术
4楼2017-05-11 15:51:10
sesame_oil
荣誉版主 (文坛精英)
- SEPI: 1
- 应助: 4518 (副教授)
- 贵宾: 2.947
- 金币: 35328.4
- 散金: 385
- 红花: 188
- 沙发: 2
- 帖子: 18585
- 在线: 536.5小时
- 虫号: 1188734
- 注册: 2011-01-12
- 专业: 计算机应用技术
- 管辖: 论文投稿
5楼2017-05-11 16:00:29
6楼2017-05-11 20:38:59