24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

ydtangl

金虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 408.9
散金: 42
红花: 1
帖子: 70
在线: 72.7小时
虫号: 934548
注册: 2009-12-28
性别: GG
专业: 配位化学

[求助] 求助精修审稿意见怎么解决 xi2004老师已有1人参与

首先衷心地感谢xi2004老师的帮助。
我投了一篇文章，其中有如下审稿意见怎样解决和回复？求各位大侠帮助。
For example, the disorder in the water molecule is not addressed. For the authors consideration, the use of the PART instruction can help separate interaction between the two disordered components of the water molecule.

The authors have outdated references/template for their software. The software used in refining the structure is SHELXL-2014, not SHELXL-97 as stated in the body text. This and the appropriate references should be corrected and updated. The contraction of the data to 50 deg. in 2-theta and the omission of the [1 0 0] reflection should also be noted in the refinement section.

Examining the model, the authors have multiple instances of HTAB. It is not clear why there are more than one set of HTAB instructions. This also leads me to ask: why were these metrics not discussed? As noted above the water molecule at the very least is involved in hydrogen-bonding.

这个数据是用shelxl97解析的，但是上传时需要用shelxl2014处理，于是我用2014精修了几轮，上传，没有出现错误。现在审稿专家就此提出了上述问题？希望各位大侠帮忙看看，谢谢各位！！！@xi2004

[ Last edited by sty112 on 2017-4-24 at 09:42 ]

回复此楼