24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者ugent将赠送您 10 个金币

ugent

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 3 (幼儿园)
金币: 45.1
帖子: 20
在线: 23.9小时
虫号: 3298072
注册: 2014-06-29
专业: 光子与光电子器件

[求助] 人生第一篇论文（laser photonics reviews）大修后的意见+亲测，催稿很有效已有1人参与

测试、数据去年10月份就搞定了，今年年初写了篇会议，然后申美国签证，然后数据后期加工了下（加了些理论的解释、仿真），就拖到8月底才投出去

11月上返回修改意见，应该是大修，两个审稿人加起来提了12条意见，不过这些意见要么是要求加reference，要么是很positive的语气要求提供一些细节、detailed discussion，所以就信心满满的改了。

11月底提交，因为圣诞临近，教授们和自己都要出去holiday了，所以今天上午催了一下（小弟是急性子。。。天不怕地不怕），问能否尽量假期前返回审稿意见。。。然后中午就神奇般的收到了邮件，更有意思的是，邮件只附列了一个审稿人的意见。。。我猜莫非是编辑收到我催的邮件后，不等第二个审稿人的意见直接给我发来了....这编辑人也太好了吧。。。

附上审稿意见，请问这样子的意见还有可能悲剧么？：

Thank you for submitting your manuscript "xxx" to Laser & Photonics Reviews.

You will be pleased to know that your manuscript has been reviewed and recommended for publication pending satisfactory revisions. The reviewer comments and an Editorial Note are attached below.

I invite you to respond to the comments and make the necessary revisions to your manuscript.
......
The deadline for the submission of this revision is 21 Jan 2016.

Once we receive your revised manuscript, we will provide a final decision as soon as possible.

-------------------------------
REVIEWER REPORT:
-------------------------------

COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:

Reviewer #1: The authors have adequately responded to my comments and the manuscript can be accepted for publication. The only thing they should add is a paragraph explaining the simulation process (answer to subquestion 3, comment 1). Readers should be able to find more about the simulations (length, resolution, fitting process, circuit model, fitting parameters).

Editorial Note:

- Please shorten your abstract to 150-200 words. Please prevent wordings such as "for the first time".
- Please rename chapter 7 in "Conclusion and Outlook" and feel free to add some sentence towards an Outlook.
- Please carefully check the sentences/language/vocabulary in your manuscript once more.
- You may reduce "we"/"our" in the text, e.g. please consider to change this in the figure captions.
- Optional: You may consider to change the title (e.g. remove the ":"