24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

1501311

木虫 (著名写手)

应助: 6 (幼儿园)
贵宾: 0.5
金币: 2811.7
散金: 10
红花: 5
帖子: 2533
在线: 415小时
虫号: 610420
注册: 2008-09-23
性别: GG
专业: 无机材料化学

[求助] 如何回答主编关于电池和超电的问题？已有1人参与

小弟投了篇文章，其中一个审稿人从全局的角度问了一些问题，具体如下：
The authors report the electrochemistry of a macropourous carbon/Co3O4 material. The electrochemistry shows more of a battery type behaviour rather than capicitive, so the relevence of the high capacitance numbers quoted is misleading. Ni and Co oxides have uses in hybrid devices as the battery type electrode (battery/supercaps). Authors need to clarify the technology their material is suited for. What is also missing is the more relevent volumetric measure of charge or capacity stored the thin nature of the electrode (low loading) and its large porosity probably results in a impractical electrode for real world devices. Though the material and electrochemical charactisation has been carried out competitantly the analysis needs improving and clarification to avoid confusing batteries with supercapacitors.
这个审稿人主要是纠结于C/Co3O4的电池还是电容材料的划分上，我的CV和GCD图如下。从图中可以看出很明显的容量性能啊，我也和其他的C/Co3O4文献比较了，很多CV和GCD也有平台，也属于超电电极材料啊。怎么来区分电池和超电呢，我有点晕了。
我该怎么回答审稿人的问题呢？？？
请大家多多指教

2.JPG