24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者chenkejie3550将赠送您 50 个金币

chenkejie3550

银虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 235.4
散金: 1054
红花: 1
帖子: 159
在线: 55.8小时
虫号: 769272
注册: 2009-05-13
性别: GG
专业: 能源化工

[求助] 审稿人和编辑的意见我一直没有弄明白什么意思已有1人参与

在ACS的JCED上投了一篇文章，审稿意见下来后进行了修改，可是编辑和审稿人又一次把相同的审稿意见给发了过来，麻烦大神给看看到底什么意思
1 Compositions are expressed as molarity, which is not accepted by the Journal. All compositions reported in tables of experimental data (Tables 2, 4–7) must be expressed as molality, mass fraction, or mole fraction. In the case of molality, the solvent must be defined clearly in the table.
Uncertainties for the compositions must also be reported as molality, mass fraction, or mole fraction. Recommendation: The authors must report molality, mass fraction, or mole fraction corresponding to each C aq and C og value.
按照这个意见我已经把表2和表4-7中的内容改成了质量分数了，为什么还让修改。
2 Literature comparison missing
Multiple references on LLE for the studied ternary systems are available. The experimental data should be compared graphically and deviations should be discussed.
ThermoLit (https://trc.nist.gov/thermolit/): For future reference, please, note that JCED expects all authors to use the free online tool ThermoLit to identify relevant literature sources in the NIST data archive with which to compare their new results. ThermoLit is intended to aid researchers and reviewers in determining relevant literature sources for a given experimental measurement. It is not intended to replace the comprehensive literature review required by all journals, because the ThermoLit database is extensive, but not comprehensive
这个是真不懂他们什么意思
3 In addition to the reviewers comments please complete the following before submitting your revision:
Keywords: Authors are required to include four to six keywords placed after the abstract.
TOC Graphic: A graphic for the Table of Contents must be supplied with each article. This graphic, in conjunction with the manuscript title, should give the reader a summary of the research described in the paper. This graphic can be no wider than 9.0 cm and no taller than 3.5 cm. Text should be limited to essential technical labels.
Funding Sources: Authors are required to report ALL funding sources and grant/award numbers. Enter all sources of funding for ALL authors in BOTH the FundRef tool in ACS Paragon Plus and in the manuscript to meet this requirement. See https://pubs.acs.org/page/4authors/funder_options.html for complete instructions.
关键词我也已经添加过了啊，五个。TOC图形也进行了说明并按照他们的格式进行了修改，基金方面也在正文中进行了说明，并在投稿信息中进行标注。为什么相同的意见返回了两次。
麻烦各位大神给小弟指条出路！

回复此楼