| 查看: 4087 | 回复: 71 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
[交流]
第一次投稿，RSC Advances 两个审稿人一个据稿，一个大修，编辑给了大修的意见
|
|||
|
本人前段时间自己写了篇通讯文章，老板看了说写的还可以，但是没有时间帮我修改还有投稿，自己投稿RSC Advances，第一次投稿，昨天编辑给了审稿意见，两个审稿人，一个大修，一个据稿，编辑给了大修的意见，不知道还有没有希望！ 下面是编辑回信还有审稿人的意见 TITLE: Facile Route to Synthesize and morphology control of Anionic Waterborne Polyurethane Hollow Microspheres via Self-Crosslinking Reaction Thank you for your submission to RSC Advances, published by the Royal Society of Chemistry. I sent your manuscript to reviewers and I have now received their reports which are copied below. I have carefully evaluated your manuscript and the reviewers’ reports, and the reports indicate that major revisions are necessary. Please submit a revised manuscript which addresses all of the reviewers’ comments. Further peer review of your revised manuscript may be needed. When you submit your revised manuscript please include a point by point response to the reviewers’ comments and highlight the changes you have made. Full details of the files you need to submit are listed at the end of this email. Referee: 1 Recommendation: Major revisions Comments: In this paper, a kind of hollow microspheres were prepared by self-crosslinking reaction of waterborne polyurethane (WPU). There are some questions as following: 1) The reaction mechanism of forming hollow microspheres was not clear. It is suggested that author give this reaction mechanism. 2) The diameter of hollow microspheres is not uniform. Could you find a method to control uniform diameter? 3) Which kind of regions that the hollow microspheres could be applied ? Additional Questions: Does the work significantly advance the understanding or development in this field? : No Are the conclusions of the work convincing and sufficiently supported by experimental evidence?: Yes Is the experimental section sufficiently detailed to allow others to reproduce the work?: No Are the reported claims adequately discussed in the context of the literature?: Yes Are the number of tables and figures in the manuscript appropriate and clear?: No Referee: 2 Recommendation: Reject Comments: Manuscript by Guo et al. describes the preparation of polyurethane hollow microsphere by self-cross linking process which is different from the process published by Li et al for waterborne hollow PU microspheres. The manuscript is well written and describes the research well. I have following suggestions and concerns for the current work: 1. The TEM and SEM images in Figure 1 indicates different size of microspheres. It seems this process doesn’t produce uniform microspheres which is the critical point in this area of research. How do authors compare these results from literature in term of advancement of process? 2. What is the average size of holes in hollow microspheres? It seems holes are not clearly visible from the images. How do you compare holes in your microspheres with similar standing literature ? 3. Figure 3 shows OM images for different carboxyl concentrations which doesn’t say anything. Could you please provide high magnification images to demonstrate that microspheres are not fusing with each other. Please also make sure statics is correct with respect to diameter of polymer microspheres. Additional Questions: Does the work significantly advance the understanding or development in this field? : No Are the conclusions of the work convincing and sufficiently supported by experimental evidence?: Yes Is the experimental section sufficiently detailed to allow others to reproduce the work?: Yes Are the reported claims adequately discussed in the context of the literature?: No Are the number of tables and figures in the manuscript appropriate and clear?: Yes 前辈们给分析一下 |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
0857调剂
已经有5人回复
-
欢迎采矿、地质、岩土、计算机、人工智能等专业的同学报考
已经有5人回复
-
279求调剂
已经有4人回复
-
284求调剂
已经有8人回复
-
材料复试调剂
已经有4人回复
-
本子写完了，给DS兄弟看了，得了92分
已经有7人回复
-
求调剂
已经有6人回复
-
材料学硕318求调剂
已经有13人回复
-
一志愿郑大材料学硕298分，求调剂
已经有5人回复
-
材料化工调剂
已经有13人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
有机
+1/100
-
安徽农业大学李亚辉教授招收生物、化学、农药学、植保类2026级博士研究生
+1/83
-
广东石油化工学院刘诗咏教授团队化学化工、材料科学等方向尚有调剂名额
+1/43
-
招中药学和药学专业研究生
+1/39
-
湖南大学材料科学与工程学院招收博士研究生
+1/35
-
26届计算机、电子信息类、电科、控制、通信考研T j信息pp骏：74+08+76+6+20/
+1/14
-
电子科技大学材料学院SFT创新中心招收2026年博士生及科研助理
+1/13
-
2026年接收考研调剂生
+1/9
-
【博士招生】湖南大学招收电化学方向审核制博士研究生
+1/7
-
邀稿综述，作者排名和工作量分工问题，存在不满和疑问。
+1/6
-
香港科技大学 招生 2026 Fall全奖博士 -- 机械/电子/材料
+1/6
-
曲阜师范大学 化学与化工学院 赵育磊教授课题组 接收报考研究生或调剂生2人
+1/6
-
湖北工业大学2026年博士研究生（生物医药专博+轻工技术与工程学博）
+1/5
-
26届计算机、电子信息类、电科、控制、通信考研T j信息pp骏：74+08+76+6+20？
+1/4
-
2026申博自荐
+1/3
-
西安工程大学环境与化学工程学院26年硕士研究生招生咨询
+1/3
-
青岛理工大学高端装备健康监测与智能运维团队接受调剂
+1/2
-
海南大学-国家级人才团队 招2026级全日制硕士研究生
+1/2
-
新加坡南洋理工大学- 光电/ 智能传感/ 脑机接口方向 博士后
+1/1
-
招调剂
+1/1
71楼2016-07-22 21:44:00
freedom251610楼2015-08-18 09:56:46
