24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者清浅112233将赠送您 9 个金币

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

清浅112233

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 70.5
帖子: 27
在线: 38.9小时
虫号: 3588009
注册: 2014-12-10
专业: 信息安全

[求助] 被IET communications 拒稿，给的意见的reject with resubmit,重投还是改投？已有3人参与

收到IET communications的信件，给的意见是reject and resubmit，如果重投的话，有三个月时间修改。编辑信件如下
Thank you for submitting your paper to IET Communications. The peer review process is now complete. The referees and I feel that your paper requires significantly more work and is not acceptable for publication in its current form. My decision is therefore to decline your paper with encouragement to submit a substantially revised paper. I appreciate that this decision will be a disappointment, but hope that you find the referees' comments (given below) useful in improving your paper.
If, following comprehensive revision, you should choose to submit your paper again, please go to https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/iet-com. Enter the Author Centre and go to 'Manuscripts with Decisions'. Click on 'Create a Resubmission' next to the paper number and follow the instructions given.
When submitting a revised manuscript, please ensure that all points raised by the referees have been actioned, and include a detailed covering letter explaining the changes made. Note that the revised paper will be treated as a completely new submission and sent out for a fresh round of reviewing.
有两个审稿人的意见，审稿人1主要说文中方法只适用于理想的情况，还有就是给出的阈值参数应该如何取（实际上，一般都是人为设定阈值），再就是应该与近几年的模型相比较；审稿人2也提出了参数的问题，要求给出实验，也说文章结构不够合理，有些部分过长，有些部分太短；两个审稿人意见都比较中肯，很认真，应该算是小同行。
编辑允许重投，但是会被作为新稿件处理，而且很可能修改后还会送到原来的审稿人。这种情况下，是修改后重投该刊还是改投他刊？请有经验的虫友给个建议吧，谢谢大家~

回复此楼