24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

vivi810613

金虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 503.2
散金: 183
红花: 5
帖子: 424
在线: 1431.4小时
虫号: 538497
注册: 2008-04-02
性别: GG
专业: 无机非金属类光电信息与功

[交流] 小木虫上的美陶审稿过程，跟偶的经历有点出入

在投美陶之前，看到小木虫上有前辈写出了美陶的审稿过程，其中说明如果是communcaiton的话，是不需要AE审的。(http://muchong.com/html/200704/460481.html)
美陶的投稿需知好象也是这么说的，可是偶最近投的一篇communcation就被AE在审了，并且已经一个多星期了，于是我壮着胆子去发信问主编这是怎么回事。主编是Dr. Halloran。下面是我写的信和主编的回信，供虫子们参考：

I asked an Associate Editor for his opinion on
this paper, even though it is a communication. I
expect the reply shortly

>16-Jun-2008
>
>JACERS-xxxxxxxxx>
>Dear Dr. Halloran:
>
>I have submitted our manuscript (JACERS-xxxxx )
>as a communication for possible publication in
>your journal. Today I find that the status of
>the manuscript is "Awaiting AE Recommendation".
>As we know from "Author guidelines", the review
>process for communications is identical to the
>articles, except that an Associate Editor. I am
>wondering whether our manuscript is considered
>as an article for possible publication in your
>journal as the "Awaiting AE Recommendation" is
>registered for our manuscript. Thank you in
>advance for your help.
>
>
>
>Sincerely,
>xxxx

从中可以看出，我的文章并没有转成article，但即使是communcaiton，主编也会让AE再审的，所以偶现在严重怀疑美陶说的34天给答复了。这是我自己的经历，供再投美陶的朋友参考了。

回复此楼