|
[交流]
文章被IEEE Transactions 录用,还算顺利,增加经验部分。
文章终于被IEEE Transactions 录用!!!高兴啊,不过后续还要处理一些麻烦的东西,如邮寄一些必要材料给期刊。
下面是录用信:
We are pleased to advise you that the above-referenced paper has
been approved for publication in the Transactions on Power
Delivery. Any reviewers' comments which may be included in this
letter are intended for information only, as your paper will be
printed without change.
Comments to the author:
Reviewer 1 Comments:
General Comments and Changes:
The authors have made the desired changes and have submitted a
good paper.
这篇文章是去年9.28投稿,去年12.28收到Review(意见不错),认真改了2个礼拜投了出去,中间一直没有消息(着急发邮件问了编辑2次都让耐心等待),今天2008.06.08终于收到录用信。
***************附上12.28的review******************
After careful review we have determined that your paper might be
of interest for publication in the IEEE Transactions on Power
Delivery, after revisions, if those revisions fully and
properly address the concerns of the reviewers. The comments
from the reviewers appearing below may include specific
revisions that are mandatory and other changes suggested. You
may have to make broader changes if necessary based on general
comments provided by the reviewers.
I wish to emphasize that this is not a conditional acceptance.
It is, rather, a recognition by our reviewers and editors that
your paper merits some interest. Your revision will be reviewed
by the same reviewers who read the current draft.
**************************************************
博士3年发了3篇外文1篇IEEE,1篇IET,1篇European Transactions,影响引子都不高(因为本人是工学),高兴啊,终于可以毕业了。
熬出头了!!!!!
*******补充点经验(看能不能得点金币或加精)***********
先说说IET Transactions的那篇文章。首先,我们专业发高水平文章还是不容易di,因为EE是个比较老的学科,基本上所有理工科学校都有这个专业,应该研究的内容基本上都被别人做过了,找到创新点也不容易(感谢老板找的方向)。接着,我运气好啊,原先根本没有想到能中IET的,想到最好的结果就是大修。因为2006年12月份这篇文章投到了IEEE Trans. on Power System,审了4个月后被编辑撤稿withdraw(虽然1个人审稿人的意见还不错)。郁闷得很,不过审稿人的意见很中肯,于是按照修改意见加了些实验数据和图,改了下英文和格式,6月底改投IET Electric Power Application,没想到2007年10月1日直接来信说录用了(并且不用修改)。
2007年9月末,将另一篇文章投去IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery。这篇文章是在IET文章上的升华,加入了新的算法,并且在其基础上作了比较,当然老板给了不少中肯的意见。因为写过IET和European Transactions两篇英文文章,发现行文(英文)容易多了,这次没有将中文翻译成英文而是直接用英文写。从2007年7月份开始,写了近半个月,写好了字斟句酌了又半个月,发给一个外国同学修改润色。8月底给老板审查,老板觉得很不错几乎没有修改就让投。本人不放心,又拿回来琢磨了半月有余才投出去。对这篇文章心里还是有底的,至少觉得质量不错,数据充分,分析有力。嘿...最后结果就jump到本贴开头。
说道写文章的经验,小弟不敢班门弄斧,小木虫上的大牛多的不计其数啊。本人觉得最重要的就是多看外国文献,看到好的idea和好的句子就记下,绝对有用!国内期刊我一般都只看看摘要和引言,最多看看国内优秀博士。(不是看不起国内的科研工作,只是本人想更多地了解国外最新科研进展和学习更好的英文表述,请不要来PK我!)
[ Last edited by onionbulb on 2008-6-10 at 19:53 ] |
|