24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

冰蓝水蜜桃19

银虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 400.5
帖子: 49
在线: 16小时
虫号: 2692963
注册: 2013-09-30
专业: 化学反应工程

[求助] 给编辑回信已有5人参与

各位虫友们，最近投了一篇文章，初审时两位审稿人都很中肯，一个审稿人说小修，提了四个问题，另一位说是修改后可以接受，提了九个问题，他们两位提的问题也都比较好回答，但是我按要求修改后，编辑直接给拒了，也没说什么理由，我想给编辑写一份信，争取一下。可以吗，应该怎么说比较好，下面是两位审稿人初审时的评价以及被拒时编辑的回信。

Reviewer #1:
In this work highly dispersed mesoporous MnOx-CeO2 hollow nanospheres were prepared by surfactant assisted supercritical anti-solvent technique for the first time. It is very interesting, as authors conclude; the prepared nanoparticles have not only higher specific areas, more uniform pores and larger pore volumes, but also richer surface active oxygen species and higher oxygen mobility contributing to higher catalytic activity compared with that fabricated without surfactants.
The work is well elaborated and its format is adequate. The main objective is clearly specified and the methodology and results are well presented. However, some points must be improved, which are considered as minor revision, as following:
Minor revisions
1) More details should be given by the authors about the phase equilibrium analysis.
2)    Although the equipment have been described in the previous publication of the authors, it is better to state again more details of the equipment as the accuracies for temperature and pressure measurements.
3) If it is possible it would be nice including the figures that show the temperature and pressure effects
4) Authors should revise the tables to correct any mistakes in the nomenclature: no space between "size" and "(" in Table 1; decide how many decimal is going to be used…
Reviewer #2: The authors prepared highly dispersed mesoporous MnOx-CeO2 hollow nanospheres by supercritical anti-solvent technique (SAS) with the aid of suitable surfactants. The materials were characterized by different techniques, and the catalytic activity of the nanospheres for low temperature deNOx with NH3 was tested. I think the manuscript is acceptable after revision.

1. For the abbreviations that are not very commonly used, such as PVP, P123, and reNOx, the full names should be provided when they appear for the first time.
2. In the Graphical Abstract, MnOx-CeO2 should be included, so that the readers can know MnOx-CeO2 particles are synthesized.
3. In Introduction, why there is the sentence " In addition, non-nitrate salt will be used as precursor, which can decrease the environmental impact of catalyst preparation in the long term." . It may make readers confusing. Are all other methods using nitrate salts?
4. In Figure 3, the number of the particles in a, b, and c are not enough. The images with more  particles should be provided.
5. It should be noted that PEG-6000 is usually not classified as a surfactant.
6. The page volume and page number of the Ref. 16 should be provided.
7. The paper is too long. Some Figures and Tables can be given as Supporting Information.
8. In the x-axis of Figures 1 and 2, the unit is the molar ratio of CO2: methanol. Please make sure that is correct.
9. The mechanism for the surfactant to prevent the aggregation of the particles should be discussed based on the interaction between the surfactant and the surface of the particles.
10. The language should be polished, and there are some minor mistakes. Please checked carefully.

这是编辑拒稿时的回信
  I have studied the revisions of the manuscript made by the authors.  Unfortunately, my conclusions are that the revisions made are of insufficient quality to allow further processing of the work. The decision on the manuscript is that it is unsuitable for publication in this journal.

As a note to the authors, the topic is of interest to readers in this journal and could be considered in a future submission provided that the quality of the English, text, discussion and presentation are substantially improved.

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

招博士已经有4人回复
救命帖已经有7人回复
限项规定已经有6人回复
西南交通大学国家级人才团队2026年博士研究生招生（考核制）—机械、材料、力学方向已经有3人回复
英文综述是否需要润色及查重已经有5人回复
为什么nbs上溴没有产物点出现呢已经有9人回复
最失望的一年已经有18人回复

1楼 2014-02-28 22:29:20

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

Silver_SY

铜虫 (小有名气)

应助: 12 (小学生)
金币: 439.9
散金: 10
红花: 3
帖子: 85
在线: 24.3小时
虫号: 2971988
注册: 2014-02-14
专业: 固体力学

【答案】应助回帖

引用回帖:

15楼: Originally posted by yuguiyan at 2014-03-01 11:48:43
请问小数位一致是小数点后位数一样还是有效数字一样啊？
...

decide how many decimal is going to be used

decimal 是小数位
不过具体问题具体分析了
一般要求小数位一致会说 decimal place 他只说decimal 而且还忘了复数加s
decimal本身是小数的意思
难道是文你要用多少个小数数字。。所以只有你自己斟酌了
有效数字一般是effective(significant) figure 位数是places

对于同一表格同一参数小数位数有效数字位数都应当尽量保持一致