24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

yanchao504

铁虫 (正式写手)

应助: 4 (幼儿园)
金币: 3390.2
散金: 2286
红花: 6
帖子: 984
在线: 282.8小时
虫号: 1160390
注册: 2010-12-01
性别: GG
专业: 作物栽培与耕作学

[求助] SSSAJ稿件被拒求各位给点意见已有1人参与

各位编辑给的意见，如下：想请各位给点建议，下一步除了按审稿人意见修改，还应该做点什么，另投他刊还是选择改后重投，这是我第一次投外刊，很多地方不了解，希望有经验的朋友们帮帮忙！谢谢了！我做的内容是“水稻秸秆还田土壤溶液中速效磷的变化”，我感觉是一个审稿人和编辑没看懂我的文章，现在很纠结，不知道该怎么办了！！！

A number of critical issues were identified with the manuscript. I raise two of these issues in particular. First, two reviewers indicated that the manuscript lacks novelty. That is, it is unclear how this study advances our understanding of the science in this area of research.

Second, the reviewers identified that utilization of soil solution data only, and no data on soil P sorption, is a major limitation of the study.

In addition, all reviewers identified issues in the presentation of the results and in the quality of the writing style. I must therefore recommend that this manuscript be rejected for publication in SSSAJ. Unfortunately, given the important limitations to the study, I think it is unlikely that the manuscript could be revised to a form which is suitable for publication in SSSAJ.

回复此楼