[交流] 唉，自己也卷入口水仗了 已有1人参与

过去一直看大牛们口水，比如Don Truhlar对阵Thomasi、Don Truhlar对阵Warshel等等（1980年代有个人在Science上发comment骂Martin Karplus，结果那一年之后，世界上再也没有这个人的文章了）。 结果，最近投稿被骂了，而且审稿人非常民科： The reference given for this is a paper by Prof. A (不便提具体名字，采用化名) and coworkers, but the recent papers by Prof. A and coworkers have many misconceptions, which I cannot begin to unravel here. 我们的回击： We would like to thank the reviewer for his great professionalism in his comments about research of people who are not even involved in the present study. Just small remark: Professor A is a world-level famous researcher with numerous publications in top journals from PNAS to Science and Nature. His recent "collaborators" include Nobel laureates and other very famous researches in the field who work in top schools. I'm sure the Editor will be pleased to see that reviewing process can be also considered by reviewers as an opportunity to discuss research of other people.

回复此楼