24小时热门版块排行榜

南方科技大学公共卫生及应急管理学院2025级博士研究生招生报考通知

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

chfwpp

铜虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 374.6
红花: 1
帖子: 68
在线: 53.5小时
虫号: 1626685
注册: 2012-02-19
专业: 工程热物理相关交叉领域

[求助] Fuel的审稿建议，如何答复，求指点已有9人参与

前一段投了一篇论文到Fuel，两个月的审稿周期，编辑部让修改。由于是第一次投SCI，不知道修改意见如何答复为好，求建议，谢谢。修改意见如下：
Reviewers have now commented on your paper. You will see that they are advising that you revise your manuscript. If you are prepared to undertake the work required, I would be pleased to reconsider my decision.
Comments by Reviewer #1:

An interesting experimental facility is presented together with experimental results.

The non-uniform coefficient should be changed to some type of adimensional number. The formula could be the actual value in the orifice divided by the average of the 5 holes, this formula will provide values just over 1 if the injected quantity is higher than the average or lower than 1 if it is smaller.

Comments by Reviewer #2:

The paper on Transient measuring method for injection rate of each nozzle hole based on spray momentum flux is quite an interesting topic for characterising fuel injection system and thus this may be of interest for Fuel. The technique itself is well established and several investigations about this technique has already been published earlier and those work has been cited in the references. The form of results are very representative to the already published literature. The new contribution of this work is hole to hole spray momentum flux in a multi-hole nozzle (5 hole). So this work will add value to the existing database.

Comments by Editor:

The manuscript size is 33 pages, which is much more than the standard. Reduce the size to 25-30 pages.

You said that the black and white figures will be used in the paper edition. Then you are requested to submit B&W figures upon the first submission.
求大神们指点，如何答复才符合国外的修改意见答复的模式，和中文期刊的答复模式一样吗？还有句子什么的？要不要有一些谢谢之类的话，在什么地方说？谢谢了。
这样的审稿意见，录用几率有多大啊？因为意见里面也没说大修或小修什么的，当前的状态是Revise。

[ Last edited by chfwpp on 2014-1-11 at 09:49 ]

回复此楼