24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 619  |  回复: 0

zhuswf

新虫 (小有名气)

[求助] MnO4- 氧化CNT和Graphene模拟不能得到稳定结构

大家好!

我根据下面两篇文章的描述,利用VASP去做MnO4- 氧化CNT和Graphene的模拟。
1. Destructive Extraction of Phospholipids from E. Coli Membrane by Graphene Nanosheets
2. Mechanism of carbon nanotubes unzipping into graphene ribbons, http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3170926

对于模拟中C、Mn和O原子,我使用的赝势是直接从paw_pbe文件夹中C、Mn和O中的POTCAR
MnO4- 初始构型是四面体形状,Mn-O键长是1.622 Angstrom。然后我将MnO4-放在graphene上,距离足够近,初始距离尝试过1.1-1.4 Angstrom
然后做离子的弛豫。但是结果是graphene总是把MnO4-排斥开,两个分子之间不能成键,这和上两篇文章结果不同。

我想请问我的计算是否有错误,赝势选取是否合适?如果正确,那么弛豫的初始构型是否有问题?MnO4- 的结构和它与graphene中最近C原子的初始距离应该设为多少,键角如何?

以下是我的INCAR文件和POSCAR文件:

1. INCAR
System = Pristine Graphene
ISTART = 0
ISMEAR = 0
SIGMA = 0.1
ENCUT = 600.0
NELM = 200
ELMIN = 5
PREC = High
GGA = PE
EDIFF = 1E-06
EDIFFG = -0.01
NPAR = 8
NSW = 2000
IBRION = 2
ISIF = 2

2. POSCAR
Pure-MnO4-Product            
  10.00000000000000
     1.2211000000000001    0.0000000000000000    0.0000000000000000
     0.0000000000000000    1.2689999999999999    0.0000000000000000
     0.0000000000000000    0.0000000000000000    2.0000000000000000
     C   Mn    O
    60    1    4
Selective dynamics
Cartesian
   0.0000000000000000  0.0000000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.0000000000000000  0.2820000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.0000000000000000  0.4230000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.0000000000000000  0.7050000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.0000000000000000  0.8460000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.0000000000000000  1.1280001000000002  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  0.0000000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  0.0705000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  0.2820000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  0.2115000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  0.4230000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  0.4935000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  0.7050000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  0.6345000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  0.8460000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  0.9165000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.2442000000000000  1.1280001000000002  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.1221000000000000  1.0574999999999999  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  0.0000000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  0.0705000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  0.2820000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  0.2115000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  0.4230000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  0.4935000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  0.7050000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  0.6345000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  0.8460000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  0.9165000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.4884000000000001  1.1280001000000002  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.3663000000000000  1.0574999999999999  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  0.0000000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.0705000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  0.2820000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.2115000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  0.4230000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.4935000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  0.7050000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.6345000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  0.8460000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.9165000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.7326000000000000  1.1280001000000002  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  1.0574999999999999  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  0.0000000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  0.0705000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  0.2820000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  0.2115000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  0.4230000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  0.4935000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  0.7050000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  0.6345000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  0.8460000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  0.9165000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.9769000000000001  1.1280001000000002  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.8548000000000000  1.0574999999999999  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  0.0705000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  0.2115000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  0.4935000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  0.6345000000000001  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  0.9165000000000000  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   1.0990000000000000  1.0574999999999999  0.8000000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.5639999999999999  1.0136000000000000  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.4316000000000000  0.9199999999999999  T  T  T
   0.6105000000000000  0.6964000000000001  0.9199999999999999  T  T  T
   0.7429000000000001  0.5639999999999999  1.1073000000000002  T  T  T
   0.4781000000000000  0.5639999999999999  1.1073000000000002  T  T  T

如果您对我的计算有任何想法或建议,我都将非常感激!
回复此楼
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 zhuswf 的主题更新
信息提示
请填处理意见