| 查看: 7550 | 回复: 216 | |||
[交流]
critical reviews in solid state and materials sciences 据稿重投
|
|||
|
本人九月底在critical reviews in solid state and materials sciences投稿一篇仿生的综述，在此之前即2012年已经有一篇类似的文章发表了"biomimicry via electrospinning"，现在编辑部回信直接据稿，说文章不符合他们的期刊要求，让我另选其他期刊，但是其中一个审稿人给了不少修改意见并说修改可用。说实在的，我投稿的文章确实存在严重不足，但是经过我近一个月的修改，个人认为已经是超越了原来那一稿的，也在一定程度上做到了上述审稿人的一些修改意见，并且修改后的稿件对biomimicry via electrospinning是一种补充，更是一种进步，请问我还能重新投稿吗？如果这样，该怎么做？谢谢各位大神的回复。 注：该期刊在同类期刊排名较好，一年只有四期，大概不到一百篇文章吧。 下面是具体的回复信息： 13-Nov-2013 Dear Mr Ke: I regret to inform you that our reviewers have now considered your paper but unfortunately feel it unsuitable for publication in Critical Reviews in Solid State and Materials Sciences. For your information I attach the reviewer comments at the bottom of this email. I hope you will find them to be constructive and helpful. You are of course now free to submit the paper elsewhere should you choose to do so. Thank you for considering Critical Reviews in Solid State and Materials Sciences. I hope the outcome of this specific submission will not discourage you from the submission of future manuscripts. Sincerely, Professor Sigmund Editor in Chief, Critical Reviews in Solid State and Materials Sciences solidstateandmaterials@gmail.com Reviewer(s)' Comments to Author: Reviewer: 1 Comments to the Author In this article, the author presented an overview of various biomimetic structure fabricated by electrospinning technique. The article did cover a wide range of bio-inspired structures. However, the manuscript does not have a coherent storyline and lacks in-depth discussion in each topic picked. Thus it is recommended that the article should be revised before accepted. Some concerns/suggestions of the article are as follows: In the presentation of some biomimetic structures, the pick of the artificial surface is arbitrary while the discussion is missing. Example: Page 5, Figure 5c: from the pick of the SEM image I didn’t see anything that resemble the targeted hierarchical feather surface. Also in this section the author did not discuss anything about the artificial surface, i.e. property, mechanism except for the synthesis. Page 5, line 33: from the description of the original dissertation as presented by Dr. Ma, it is kinds of arbitrary to assert that the co—polymer fiber structure resembles the structure on butterfly wings, or at least as presented in figure 6. Page 6, figure 7c vs figure 7d and figure 7e: comparing the nature and artificial surfaces, it is kinds of dubious that they can be claimed similar. Also the discussion is not enough. Page 7, linge 5: the author just wrote “They found the structure of the prepared fibers were similar to that of the spider silk.” There is no evidence to prove this simple statement, nor any discussion about the implication and applications of this finding. This is not a general discussion or conclusion section at the end of this paper, which makes the end of this article seemingly arbitrary. In general, the author might consider present the information more logically and more in-depth, with contribution from the knowledge of the author himself rather than just describing what was done by others. Another major problem with the paper is the reproduction permission of the figures. The author just get random figures from different literatures and put them together without getting permissions. Reproduction permission needs to be obtained (possibly from the publisher) and state clearly at the end of each figure to prevent potential plagiarism problems. For a review article as this is, 41 references are far from enough. This goes back to the first point, that the author could get a more systematic view of the topics by reading more papers than just commenting on one paper in each specific topic. Page 3, line 28: the author mentioned about figure 3e, but where is it? Page 4, line 12: the author mentioned that “the diameter of setae rangs (ranges) from 3mm down to several hundred nanometres (nanometers) and most are roughly 50 micron…” This is over 4 orders of magnitude difference. Can the author assure that the setae talked about is one type of setae or there are actually several different bio-structures on water strider legs? It would be kinds of astonishing that a single type of structure can have such wide range of size distribution. The author needs to work more on the language and spelling (e.g. see previous point). If possible, work with a native speaker to make the illustration clearer. In page 6, line 10-14, why there is a sudden change in the line spacing? Reviewer: 2 Comments to the Author The writing in this paper needs substantial work. A successful review paper's primary goal is to clearly explain the work of others and to tie the research together. The paper does not clearly do this. It also appears incomplete as there are no concluding remarks. |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
体制内长辈说体制内绝大部分一辈子在底层，如同你们一样大部分普通教师忙且收入低
已经有10人回复
-
过年走亲戚时感受到了所开私家车的鄙视链
已经有9人回复
-
今年春晚有几个节目很不错，点赞！
已经有10人回复
-
情人节自我反思：在爱情中有过遗憾吗？
已经有10人回复
-
基金正文30页指的是报告正文还是整个申请书
已经有5人回复
» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
天津科技大学海洋与环境学院殷焕顺团队招博士生1名---分析化学领域
+1/81
-
大连海事大学轮机学院尚有博士名额
+2/66
-
一个陌生女人的来信
+1/59
-
上海理工大学2026年系统科学学科海外骨干教师招聘启事
+2/34
-
海法大学线上开放日
+1/33
-
国家级青年人才课题组招收2026级硕士研究生
+1/30
-
清华大学深圳国际研究生院招聘-博士后（长期有效）
+1/27
-
英国布里斯托大学诚招博士生，博士后和联合培养生
+1/17
-
代朋友发 88公务员诚征男友
+1/17
-
深圳大学26级土木工程博士招生
+1/9
-
香港科技大学（广州）微电子学域助理教授招募全奖博士生与研究助理（纳米器件）
+1/9
-
武汉纺织大学全国重点实验室陈嵘教授团队招收硕士研究生
+1/8
-
天津医科大学基础医学院张恒课题组博士后招聘
+1/6
-
全奖博士 英国利物浦大学+台湾清华大学 双博士学位
+1/5
-
澳科大招收2026秋纳米医学/生物材料方向全奖博士研究生（3月5日18:00截止）
+1/5
-
英国南安普顿大学禅铎课题组诚招气候动力方向博士后
+1/5
-
澳科大诚招2026年秋季硕士研究生（药物递送/生物材料方向，3月5日18:00报名截止）
+1/3
-
苏州大学招收有机化学（材料）方向博士生，2026年9月入学
+1/2
-
华中科技大学/武汉纺织大学联合招收博士后
+1/1
-
大学教授诚征结婚女友@坐标长春
+1/1
3楼2013-11-14 10:22:48
6楼2013-11-14 10:35:07
7楼2013-11-14 10:52:32
13楼2013-11-14 11:05:15
23楼2013-11-14 11:33:12
24楼2013-11-14 11:34:16
36楼2013-11-14 11:52:15
39楼2013-11-14 12:03:15
45楼2013-11-14 12:13:08
49楼2013-11-14 12:18:13
50楼2013-11-14 12:18:14
简单回复
nono20092楼
2013-11-14 10:19
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福
2013-11-14 10:26
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
shichong5楼
2013-11-14 10:27
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
2013-11-14 10:57
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
dlbrians9楼
2013-11-14 11:02
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
readytogo10楼
2013-11-14 11:03
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
aboluo19833111楼
2013-11-14 11:04
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
lmz110112楼
2013-11-14 11:04
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
shinyzd14楼
2013-11-14 11:08
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
支持
lefantian12215楼
2013-11-14 11:17
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
gyfwon16楼
2013-11-14 11:18
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
sddhxr17楼
2013-11-14 11:19
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
wuning88818楼
2013-11-14 11:23
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
上海四缤19楼
2013-11-14 11:23
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
祝福
jibif20楼
2013-11-14 11:23
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
假大空21楼
2013-11-14 11:28
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
clarktao22楼
2013-11-14 11:31
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
段小飞25楼
2013-11-14 11:34
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
ycsdzg26楼
2013-11-14 11:34
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
doctorbang27楼
2013-11-14 11:36
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
time8828楼
2013-11-14 11:37
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
wlxiao29楼
2013-11-14 11:37
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
xiaomu7830楼
2013-11-14 11:38
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
zhoupeng8731楼
2013-11-14 11:40
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
·
huaxiduan32楼
2013-11-14 11:42
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
tianjun50233楼
2013-11-14 11:49
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
长风相伴34楼
2013-11-14 11:51
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
clszdy35楼
2013-11-14 11:52
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
virologik37楼
2013-11-14 12:00
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
zhangheng07938楼
2013-11-14 12:01
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
xianzhi201040楼
2013-11-14 12:09
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
haixiawu41楼
2013-11-14 12:10
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
shiyiren42楼
2013-11-14 12:11
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
zxf_201543楼
2013-11-14 12:12
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
gter_wang44楼
2013-11-14 12:12
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
liulinkk46楼
2013-11-14 12:14
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
zhiyongwang47楼
2013-11-14 12:15
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与
handsomewood48楼
2013-11-14 12:16
回复
aming_1230(金币+1): 谢谢参与