[交流] INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY 投稿问题！ 已有3人参与

小弟的一篇文章投到International Journal of Hydrogen Energy，审稿人提了五个意见。编辑的回复是positive feedbacks。意见如下： Reviewer #1: 1.        One page 3, the authors say ' Currently, most of hydrogen is generated from natural gas and fossil fuels via steam reforming and coal gasification', it is kind of confusing, because natural gas is one kind of fossil fuels, thus I would suggest the author rewrite this sentence to make it more make sense. 2.        Sometimes the authors report the produced gas in volume, which highly depends on temperature and pressure, but the authors do not specify the temperature and pressure. 3.        Sometimes the authors leave a space between the numerical value and unit, while sometimes they do not, please unify the format throughout the papers. 4.        There are some grammar errors, so they have to correct them before publication. Such as on page 3, 'Biomass as a kind of renewable energy has more advantages and less impact to environment than fossil fuels [12], which can be transformed into hydrogen with CO2 neutral and low sulfur content [13,14]', I do not know if 'which' in this sentence points to, the fossil fuel or biomass? 5.        The authors say that 'Each experiment was carried out three times in order to determine the repeatability of each experiment and the reliability of the system, at the same conditions' , but they do not mention their error range for the values they report in the table and figures. 有经验的虫友说说，这是大修还是小修？我感觉好像是小修，接到审稿意见两天后把修改稿提交了。 如果是小修的话，编辑还会不会送审啊？？？谢谢

回复此楼