JOURNAL OF ALLOYS AND COMPOUNDS这个比较快,给你写下我的经历吧~希望您看一下。
投出去一个多月返回大修,两个审稿人问了二三十个问题加起来,
Reviewer #1: The article is new and original, with logical structure. Though it needs some revisions.
以下是问题数了以下大概十三四个
Reviewer #2:The paper reports on the ....... The introduction part is to be organized thoroughly with proper referencing for .... as thermoelectric material. The focus of the present study is interesting. I would expect that authors provide information so that readers can easily compare their findings with previous reports.
接下来又是是几个问题。
当时感觉崩溃,但是沉下心来补实验回答问题搞了20天的样子饭都忘记吃来不及啊,甚至都有通宵改论文的想法,还好被我即使打消了念头,最后提交上去,足足回复了16页,5000字统计了一下,大概19天以后,其中一个审稿人回复如下;
Reviewer #4: Manuscript Number:
Title:XXXXXXXXX
The authors reported the......
The manuscript is potentially interesting, the academic value of this study is communicated to the readers and it is well organized, I have checked all refree comments and authors respond. The Authors are carefully respond to all refreee comments and revised the manuscript according to their comments. I don't have additonal comments, I think revised manuscript is ready to be pusblished XXXX, I recommend the manuscript to be published in xxxxx.
Reviewer #5: The authors have well taken most of the previous reviewers' comments into account, and I estimate that their manuscript could be suitable for publication after some revisions.
可能有一个审稿人没有审稿,编辑又重新找了一个审稿人审稿,但是又问了13个问题直接崩溃,给了小修然后加紧修改加班加点五六天搞定,又花了两三天看文章,一句一句的看,最后提交上去以后三天之后直接收到编辑的回复:
I have the pleasure of informing you that your paper has been accepted for publication in theXXXXX
三天直接接受都没有返回审稿人那,回复第二次10页,编辑都感动了有木有???