8楼: Originally posted by kfc275 at 2013-04-25 17:32:19
这不是大修吗

2楼: Originally posted by 冰河子 at 2013-04-23 15:09:35
好好修改  必有希望

3楼: Originally posted by yanghxny at 2013-04-23 17:22:59
按要求去做就有希望。

4楼: Originally posted by makunjida at 2013-04-23 17:51:14
大修，有希望，但要认真改。问题很尖锐，论文需要大改才行，否则你很难回答。

10楼: Originally posted by kanyechris at 2013-04-25 18:56:49
看你修改的情况了，我最近投的一篇5分的文章，审稿人口气还没这么硬，两个同意发，一个说publishable 。但是还是觉得不好好改会被拒掉，所以完全按照主编的意思改吧。

11楼: Originally posted by kanyechris at 2013-04-25 18:58:19
大修的说话一般是：this paper may be publishable with major revision，所以感觉比大修严重点吧，不过看各个杂志了...

6楼: Originally posted by 流水一线 at 2013-04-25 16:59:19
不好讲，得看是什么期刊。楼主投的是哪个啊？

8楼: Originally posted by kfc275 at 2013-04-25 17:32:19
这不是大修吗

19楼: Originally posted by yuanboyu at 2013-05-01 11:13:41
恭喜楼主！