24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

wosh

木虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 1884
帖子: 229
在线: 36.8小时
虫号: 634517
注册: 2008-10-23
性别: GG
专业: 信号理论与信号处理

[求助] 论文2审大修，麻烦大家指点一下，还有希望么

春天投的第一篇SCI，审稿5个月后，一审两个审稿人，都提了很多问题，编辑给了大修。认真修改投出后今天审稿意见回来了，结果还是大修。。。感觉都没啥希望了。说下这次两个审稿人得情况，一个审稿人就提了一个小点，说改后就可以接收了；关键在第二个审稿人，直接列了3条意见，说的内容跟第一次完全不相关，而且很简单，不是问题就是陈述：1. 文章中部分公式与两篇参考文献中的公式相同（推导出来就这样，我没办法啊）。2. 这个和第一个审稿人说的那个点一样，是需要改的。3.就一句话：“Not enough experiments have been done to support the claimed advantage（一审的时候他提了8个问题，也没说试验不够，而且都认真回答他的问题了）。” 最后他说：“The above problems are fatal to this paper. I am unable to recommend the publication of this manuscript in XXX.”
编辑给的回信是：
Thank you for submitting your revised paper XXX. The revised paper has been considered but Dr. XX(这个名字是杂志的主编，上次回信就是他给回的，这次这封信是负责审理我稿件的编辑回的) would like to see the reviewers' comments below addressed before the paper is finally accepted.
When submitting the further revised manuscript, please explain the changes made. Please try to submit your revised manuscript within 30 days. If you are unable to meet this date, please let me know at your earliest convenience. Should the revision take longer than four months, it will be treated as a new paper submission to the journal.
If you have any difficulties submitting your revised manuscript please do not submit it as a new manuscript. Instead please contact me on the above e-mail account attaching the covering letter and the revised paper in word (.doc) or Postscript (.ps) formats. We will then upload your revised paper for you. Please note that we cannot accept .pdf versions for revised papers.

麻烦大家看看还有希望吗？我改怎么办？编辑的信其实我看的有点晕，尤其是第一段，谢谢了

[ Last edited by wosh on 2012-12-20 at 20:23 ]

回复此楼