[求助] partial pair correlation function 的问题

下面是referee的comment，前面的都很好理解，也能回复，就是最后一句括号里面的内容，没搞明白，这是第一次听到有人提出这种说法，是不是referee委婉的表示他根本不相信Kohara的结果？如果是这种情况，应该怎么回答? It is also not strongly convincing that the authors compare their partial pair correlation functions with liquid structure. More direct validation can be obtained if they use published amorphous pair correlation functions (e.g. for Ge20Te80) instead of the liquid ones. (I am also not fully convinced by the shallow minima of the partial g(r)'s of Kohara et al) referee提到的数据是图中黑色线的那一组。

回复此楼