小虫今天刚收到Automatica的审稿意见：Provisionally rejected-may be resubmitted as brief paper。一共有三个审稿人，两个说可发表（其中一个明确说值得发表，另外一个说认真修改他的问题就可以发表），第三位专家没有明确表态，但是审稿意见很细且比较容易回答。
在此，请教各位虫友前辈，复审的时候会换审稿人吗？这样的意见录用的可能性大吗？
有没有给该期刊审稿的虫友，审稿人给意见的时候分为几档？（比如Accept, Minor revisions, Major revisions，等）
[ Last edited by allen_baobao on 2012-4-16 at 23:00 ]
Actually it was rejected in the current case. However, you can resubmit is as a brief paper. It means that your manuscript is too long and it isnot neccessary.
回复此楼
ACTAC888
+2/96
