24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

ltyan

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 159.1
帖子: 17
在线: 163.2小时
虫号: 1678812
注册: 2012-03-09
专业: 高分子物理与高分子物理化

[交流] 大牛帮忙看看PRL的Edotor意见已有11人参与

一篇文章投到PRL,等了一个月，下面是Editor的回复：

Dear Dr. xxxx,

The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referees.

A critique drawn from the reports appears below. On this basis, we
judge that the paper is not appropriate for Physical Review Letters,
but might be suitable for publication in another journal, possibly with
some revision. Therefore, we recommend that you submit your manuscript
elsewhere.

If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
recommendations and criticisms.

Yours sincerely,
xxxxxxx

三个审稿人，
A的意见摘要:“xxxxxx. If the authors are willing to thoroughly cite this literature and present a convincing argument that what they have done adds to the extensive picture that has already been developed into exactly this sort of system then I might possibly be willing to reconsider my decision.”

B提了一大堆问题，说是改完再审

C肯听了这篇文章的结果和方法，但是建议投more special journal.

本人感觉这些问题都可以回答掉，于是想argue一下。由于缺乏这方面的经验，请大牛给些建议吧，先谢谢了！

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

博士读完未来一定会好吗已经有21人回复
导师想让我从独立一作变成了共一第一已经有5人回复
到新单位后，换了新的研究方向，没有团队，持续积累2区以上论文，能申请到面上吗已经有11人回复
读博已经有4人回复
JMPT 期刊投稿流程已经有4人回复
心脉受损已经有5人回复
Springer期刊投稿求助已经有4人回复
小论文投稿已经有3人回复
Bioresource Technology期刊，第一次返修的时候被退回好几次了已经有9人回复
申请2026年博士已经有6人回复

1楼2012-03-09 21:16:04

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

eseayl

至尊木虫 (职业作家)

应助: 29 (小学生)
金币: 17430.7
散金: 1913
红花: 36
帖子: 3126
在线: 2879.9小时
虫号: 590286
注册: 2008-08-31
专业: 地层学

★
小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包，谢谢回帖

我的一篇prl意见前面一段跟你一模一样，但是没有建议再投。反正给你修改机会就好啊。
我另外一篇prl的意见是重投（相当于返修），是这样表述的
The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
We append pertinent comments.

If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all recommendations and criticisms.