Originally posted by alex1304 at 2011-05-21 16:48:38:
Dear ×××,

I have received independent reviews of your manuscript recommending its rejection to major revision. After careful consideration, I am rejecting it. I have included their comments  ...

Originally posted by ggwwmm1234 at 2011-05-21 20:41:14:
  楼主的命运跟我一样，不过我更惨，审稿人先让大修（没提什么意见），大修之后审稿人又直接拒（又没给任何理由，无非就是说语言不痛，做的东西没新意）

Originally posted by shy2400 at 2011-05-21 20:43:51:
审稿人意见这么尖锐。。。当然主编会考虑给毙掉的啊。。。

另外，楼主，为什么就一个审稿人的意见呢？如果是一个审稿人的话，主编很定是最后决断人。

Originally posted by alex1304 at 2011-05-21 21:25:23:
就一个审稿意见。
我推荐了三个，估计他就选了其中一个。

Originally posted by alex1304 at 2011-05-21 16:48:38:
Dear ×××,

I have received independent reviews of your manuscript recommending its rejection to major revision. After careful consideration, I am rejecting it. I have included their comments  ...