24小时热门版块排行榜

>论坛更新日志 (1733)
>休闲灌水 (43)
>导师招生 (34)
>虫友互识 (31)
>硕博家园 (28)
>考研 (25)
>公派出国 (24)
>考博 (21)
>论文投稿 (21)
>基金申请 (18)
>教师之家 (18)
>博后之家 (15)
>论文道贺祈福 (11)
>文献求助 (10)
>找工作 (9)
>药学 (6)

返回列表

好好生活

木虫 (著名写手)

应助: 4 (幼儿园)
金币: 2883.4
帖子: 1204
在线: 351.2小时
虫号: 316003

[交流] 请做葡萄糖传感的人帮忙看一下Biosensors and bioelectronics的审稿意见

我做的是葡萄糖的无酶传感，要大修。
审稿人1：
1. Evidence of the electrooxidation of glucose on the structured gold electrode do not directly means that such system can be used as glucose sensor. What is the selectivity of such electrochemical systems towards other aliphatic aldehydes and other monosaccharides, like galactose and other reducing disaccharides, like maltose? Introduction can be shirked and focused on glucose analytical systems, but not on monosaccharides.
是不是要补充其它还原性糖的实验？审稿人提到的这几种糖，如半乳糖，麦芽糖都要做？看其它做无酶葡萄糖传感的也没有做啊~

>3. Concentration of ascorbic acid can be increased in the blood considerably during unpredicted and unexpected consumption of vitamin C by patient. Analytical system must be ready to such events.
这点怎么回答？

编辑意见：
Editors' report:
>
>An "X" has been placed before the paragraph that you need to take into consideration.
>
>1. Review Articles should present a thorough and comprehensive overview of the chosen subject and be extensively referenced and comprise around 8000 words. Authors are expected to go beyond a simple compilation of references and analyse trends, shortcomings and accomplishments in their chosen field, charting possible future directions of the research. Illustrations and summary tables are encouraged. Flexibility of presentation is permitted, but authors are urged to arrange the subject matter clearly under the general headings of Abstract, Keywords, Introduction, Main text (The heading and the sub-headings of the main text are left to author's discretion), Summary and Conclusions, Future Perspectives, Acknowledgements, References.
>
>2. Full papers should be complete descriptions of full investigations comprising around 5000 words with up to 6 single figures/tables/schemes in total, but your manuscript comprises too many figures/tables/schemes. You could use the supplemental information feature for extra figures/tables/. Supplementary files supplied will be published online alongside the electronic version of your article in Elsevier Science web products, but will not appear in the printed issue. You can find the details at http://ees.elsevier.com/bios/
>
>3. We would consider your revised manuscript for publication as a Short Communication. It should be complete descriptions of original limited investigations comprising around 3000 words with up to three single figures/tables/schemes. Alternatively, you could use the supplemental information feature for extra figures/tables/schemes. Supplementary files supplied will be published online alongside the electronic version of your article in Elsevier Science web products, but will not appear in the printed issue. You can find the details at http://ees.elsevier.com/bios/
>
……
首先我没看到哪段前标记了“X”，是不是编辑提的每一点都要改？
第3点意见就是让我把全文改成通讯？

[ Last edited by 好好生活 on 2010-12-10 at 20:25 ]

回复此楼