24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

xiaoyezi8085

至尊木虫 (职业作家)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 16679.5
散金: 487
红花: 4
帖子: 3157
在线: 551.5小时
虫号: 682308
注册: 2008-12-26
性别: MM
专业: 催化化学

[交流] 【求助】审稿意见中的这些话是什么意思？

做的光解水制氢，审稿意见回来，只有一个，给的肯定意见，但感觉提的问题有点犀利，不太能确定，在此请教下大家。

1.A chemical reaction scheme showing catalyst synthesis would be helpful.  Also, balance all chemical reactions on this, and on the proposed photoreaction scheme。
这点是不是要求给个反应机制呢？还是什么
2.Figure 4 needs a more detailed caption, and arrows pointing to Cu3+/2+/++ should be given.  The XPS data is questionable since the fitting requires high resolution XPS.  Some data to show that they can resolve Cu3+/2+/1+ in a standard known sample would be helpful.
这句话是不是指有些文献可以拟合出，一二三价的铜在一个催化剂样品中，还是什么？？审稿人的目的是什么？
3.In our own work in the area of hydrogen reduced catalysts, we became aware that stoichiometric (not catalytic) reactions are possible.  A rough calculation for the author's catalysts shows that about 850 -mole of reduced Cu-Ni is present in their 0.1 g catalysts.  Yields of H2 from water splitting need to be much higher overall than 850 -mole.  Thus, the question, how long do the catalysts live and what is the TOTAL  -moles H2 produced, compared with the -moles catalyst present?
这个计算是指什么计算呢？

欢迎大家指导交流。谢谢!

本文来自: 小木虫论坛 http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=2311338&fpage=1

回复此楼