24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

biozhangliang

木虫 (小有名气)

土博士

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 1615.7
散金: 130
帖子: 256
在线: 68.3小时
虫号: 528109
注册: 2008-03-18
性别: GG
专业: 环境微生物学

[交流] 二审结果出来了，给各位报告下，顺便散币求祝福和攒人品已有42人参与

二审结果终于在1个月的时候很准时的出来了，下面附上，请大家帮我看看：
Reviewers' comments:

Reviewer #1: In my opinion the authors of the manuscript took into consideration majority of the suggested changes and remarks. The revised manuscript is more readable. However, some matters concerning the measurement of the viscosity are still unclear. Authors are not informing explicitly, what type of spindle (DIN or PVS Spindles, LV Spindles, RV/HA/HB Spindles ? or some other type? )was used for measurements of the viscosity. The sentence ("The spindle for measuring the viscosity was according to the rotation per minute of spindle"

included in the response to the Reviewer, is really unclear. Please, specify the concrete type of the measuring spindle (for example: ULA-DIN-85 or LV-1, LV-2). It is very important information, necessary to reconstruction of the experiment conditions.
In my opinion, before approving the publication, shown data must be supplemented.

Reviewer #2: The modifications and improvements of this manuscript have been made according to the reviewer's commnets. Also, efforts have been made to correct all the mistakes. I have few additional comments:

Line 254-255:The reference was added as I proposed: "Sathaporn and Maki reported that the ethanol yield of 16.61% (v/v) was obtained from
255 VHG potato mash by adding amount of assimilable nitrogen (ammonium sulfate) [22]". But, in list of references I cannot see any author under [22]named Sathaporn or Maki. Probably, there is confusion about authors' first and last names. Also, there are more than two authors. So, it should be: "Srichuwong et al."
Line 263: It should be written "Kim et al." since there are four authors of this paper, not just two.

今天上午修改了下，并传了回去，希望能够有个好结果。

顺便附上以前我的帖子，给大家看看，对新虫可能还是有用，反正我是所有的过场都走到了。投稿---一审------修改------再投稿-------催稿---------二审-------再投稿

老帖地址：http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=2256618
老帖里有我的整个投稿过程，还有相关链接，各位大大祝福下我哈。

PS:现在文章接收上网了，这个帖子就当给后来人留点经验吧！

[ Last edited by biozhangliang on 2010-10-10 at 16:22 ]

回复此楼