[交流] under review 一周后变成Required Reviews Completed 已有42人参与

under review 一周后变成Required Reviews Completed 这么快，是不是很快就要被拒了？ 【昨晚发的帖子，今天下午审稿意见就回来了】三个审稿人的意见如下： Reviewer #1:  The paper can be acceptable after the minor revision. Reviewer #2:  The manuscript has several English language and grammatical errors. Therefore, recommended that the language errors should be corrected with proper construction of sentences before it is published in the XXX. Reviewer #3:  This work is appropriate to be published as a letter in XXX. Nevertheless, the following (minor) comments should be taken into account by the authors before publication. 主编给的意见：Your paper has been reviewed, and comments can be found in the report included below. Before your paper can be published, several clarifying amendments have to be made and major technical revisions of several points are required. I would appreciate if you could give these comments your prompt attention. Please comply with the criticism raised by the referee in the revised manuscript. 谢谢大家的回复 [ Last edited by zhaocl on 2010-4-16 at 16:38 ]

回复此楼