| ²é¿´: 1165 | »Ø¸´: 15 | ||
| µ±Ç°Ö÷ÌâÒѾ´æµµ¡£ | ||
feitian1984Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
|
[½»Á÷]
´ó¼Ò°ïÎÒ¿´¿´ÎÒÕâÆªÎÄÕÂÖеļ¸ÂÊÓжà´ó
|
|
|
´ó¼ÒºÃ£¬ÓÐûÓÐÄÇλͶ¹ýÑÇÖÞµØÑ§ÔÓÖ¾£¨Journal of Asian Earth Sciences)£¿ÎÒͶÁËһƪ£¬ÉóÁË¿ìÒ»Äê²ÅÉ󻨡£ÖÕÓÚÉó»ØÀ´ÁË£¬Éó¸åÒâ¼ûÊÇ£º The reviewers have commented on your above paper. They indicated that it is not acceptable for publication in its present form. However, if you feel that you can suitably address the reviewers' comments (included below), I invite you to revise and resubmit your manuscript. Please carefully address the issues raised in the comments. If you are submitting a revised manuscript, please also: a) outline each change made (point by point) as raised in the reviewer comments AND/OR b) provide a suitable rebuttal to each reviewer comment not addressed To submit your revision, please do the following:****** Reviewers' comments: This paper deals with *******. The two reviewers agreed that this paper merits publication at the Journal of Asian Earth Sciences. Nevertheless, vital revisions are necessary to improve the manuscript for a publishable condition. These comments would surely be very useful to the authors to extensively improve their manuscript. Reviewer #2: The manuscript by ***makes an important contribution to better understand the ******, by using the technique of ******. The ******have been found in fine-grained mudstone, shale or chalk only in Cretaceous and Cenozoic basins. The system was first recognized in Upper Miocene in the deep water zone in South China Sea with high quality 3D seismic data using seismic attributes. DETAILED COMMENTS ****** Reviewer #3: The manuscript titled "******" by ****** documents the findings of a 3D seismic cube which shows ******within some particular horizons, which they argue may serve as the pathway linking the source rocks and reservoir. Overall the dataset is interesting and worth publishing. However, there are some major concerns: 1. ******2. ******3. ***** 4. ****** There are some minor comments: ****** In sum, the manuscript needs modification before it is ready for publication. Using the geometric information of the******imaged by this study, the authors have made interesting observations and proposal important interpretation. On the other hand, it will be good to use additional information to better support the discussion about the formation and implications of the ******. The authors have good command of English, but there are still many loose-ends in the manuscript that they can work on during the revision. The seismic data look great, and it will be great to make this manuscript more process-oriented so similar work can be applied in other regions. ÒÔÉÏÊÇÁ½¸öÉó¸åÈ˵ÄÉó¸åÒâ¼û¡£ ¸÷λ¹ýÀ´µÄ¸ßÈË£¬Ö¸µãһϣ¬ÕâÆªÎÄÕµÄÖеļ¸ÂʸßÂð£¿Õâ¸öÔÓ־̫ÂýÁË£¬ÎÒÅÂÐ޸ĺóÓÖÒªºÃ³¤µÄʱ¼ä£¬ÒªÊDZ»¾ÜÁË£¬¾ÍÌ«±¯¾çÁË¡£Çë·¹ý£¬ÖªµÀµÄÒ»¶¨²»Ï§´Í½Ì°¡£¬ÏÈлл¸÷λ³æ³æÁË¡£ [ Last edited by feitian1984 on 2010-1-18 at 17:36 ] |
feitian1984
Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 4 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 326.8
- É¢½ð: 444
- Ìû×Ó: 816
- ÔÚÏß: 42.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 940460
- ×¢²á: 2010-01-11
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
2Â¥2010-01-18 17:14:02
wxchen326
Òø³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 0 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1458.6
- É¢½ð: 100
- Ìû×Ó: 166
- ÔÚÏß: 146Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 757925
- ×¢²á: 2009-04-26
3Â¥2010-01-18 17:20:24
sanshyuan
¾èÖú¹ó±ö (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 8 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ¹ó±ö: 0.001
- ½ð±Ò: 2883.8
- É¢½ð: 12412
- ºì»¨: 3
- Ìû×Ó: 2897
- ÔÚÏß: 482.7Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 543520
- ×¢²á: 2008-04-11
- רҵ: »úе²âÊÔÀíÂÛÓë¼¼Êõ
4Â¥2010-01-18 17:22:44
feitian1984
Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 4 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 326.8
- É¢½ð: 444
- Ìû×Ó: 816
- ÔÚÏß: 42.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 940460
- ×¢²á: 2010-01-11
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
5Â¥2010-01-18 17:22:56
feitian1984
Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 4 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 326.8
- É¢½ð: 444
- Ìû×Ó: 816
- ÔÚÏß: 42.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 940460
- ×¢²á: 2010-01-11
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
6Â¥2010-01-18 17:37:33
gvvsx200
½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)
- Ó¦Öú: 0 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 595.9
- ºì»¨: 3
- Ìû×Ó: 236
- ÔÚÏß: 16.8Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 822827
- ×¢²á: 2009-08-05
- רҵ: ´ß»¯£¬±íÃæ£¬²ÄÁÏ
7Â¥2010-01-18 18:23:40
Ñà¹Âºè
½ð³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 1 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 1561.4
- Ìû×Ó: 2127
- ÔÚÏß: 183.1Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 843099
- ×¢²á: 2009-09-08
- רҵ: Éùѧ
¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
|
´óÐÞ£¬»ú»á½Ï´ó The two reviewers agreed that this paper merits publication at the Journal of Asian Earth Sciences |

8Â¥2010-01-18 18:28:15
feitian1984
Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 4 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 326.8
- É¢½ð: 444
- Ìû×Ó: 816
- ÔÚÏß: 42.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 940460
- ×¢²á: 2010-01-11
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
9Â¥2010-01-18 19:11:32
feitian1984
Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)
- Ó¦Öú: 4 (Ó×¶ùÔ°)
- ½ð±Ò: 326.8
- É¢½ð: 444
- Ìû×Ó: 816
- ÔÚÏß: 42.6Сʱ
- ³æºÅ: 940460
- ×¢²á: 2010-01-11
- ÐÔ±ð: GG
- רҵ: º£ÑóµØÖÊѧ
10Â¥2010-01-18 19:12:46














»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥