|
|
第一次Science投稿，二位审稿人基本支持，但认为证据不充分。另一位坚决反对，反对意见比原文还长，没通过。
第二次投稿，我们增加了一些标本，证据非常充实。但是直接被编辑打回来，没有送审，因为他参考了第一次的意见，说是争议太大。
Thank you for submitting your manuscript“" to Science. I*m sorry for the delay in notifying you of our decision. We appreciate that you have revised and improved on your earlier submission. However, after some consideration,
we have decided against sending your paper out for in-depth review.
Although your analysis is interesting, and now stronger, in view of the
prior decision and many other papers we have under consideration, we
felt that your paper is less competitive for our very limited space. We
are therefore notifying you so that you can seek publication elsewhere.
We now receive many more interesting papers than we can publish. We
therefore send for in-depth review only those papers most likely to be
ultimately published in Science. Papers are selected on the basis of
discipline, novelty, and general significance, in addition to the usual
criteria for publication in specialized journals. Therefore, our
decision is not necessarily a reflection of the quality of your research
but rather of our stringent space limitations.
We wish you every success when you submit the paper elsewhere.
Sincerely,
Deputy Editor, Physical Sciences |
|
回复此楼
